Pizza Review
Ciro's Pizzeria & Beerhouse is permanently closed. This review is for Prince Street Pizza at 415 Market Street. Rating for the pepperoni square only. They are out here murdering an institution. The pepperoni square from Prince Street Pizza is arguably my favorite slice of all time. I originally rated the round cheese slice at their NY location an 8.5 with their pepperoni square easily being 9.1+ This slice is not at the Prince Street Pizza standard. It was overly charred and lacked chew and flavor. The pepperonis are still some of the best in the business and the bit of spice that I did get was lovely. It is still a decent slice overall; but knowing how good it should be, I left extremely disappointed. Looking through the numerous positive Yelp reviews, maybe this was a bad night for the shop. Or maybe folks just don’t realize how amazing Prince Street Pizza really is.