Coal Fire Pizza

Has some flopn could have been crisper them for suren It would be in the 8.

I first reviewed this pizza back around 2020 and this was my favorite pie until today. I’ve been hyping this place up saying the best pizza around. This time was not that. Super floppy, undercooked and they put way too much sugar in the sauce. The sauce is what sets this apart from everyone else but holey moley. Maybe a bad day for them so it’s still worth a try if you are in the area.

The worst pizza I have ever eaten. I feel so bad but I have to review it.. WAY WAY WAYYYY TOO SWEET. I couldn’t even eat without gagging from how sweet it was. I can’t understand how anyone is rating this over a 5, let alone an 8! Also it was so floppy, I don’t think it was all the way cooked. Shame.

Crust was good, but had a serious amount of flop. We tried all three of their sauces and found them all to be too sweet. Probably would not choose to eat this pizza again, it just was not my style.

Ask for their signature sauce. Cheese, sauce, undercarriage, crust all good

Solid pizza. Signature sauce is the way to go, thin pizza super light and crispy. No flop. Great pie.

Pretty good. Good crisp. Sauce is a classic flavor.

Great char on the pizza. Also loved the signature sauce

Think it’s ever so slightly inferior to the one in Odenton but still the goat. Great flavor l

Pizza time, Frederick md Only place on the app with above an 8 in the area, and I’d say it’s probably deserved. Good oven, fantastic place, tried the signature sauce and was very sweet and flavorful. Little bit of a flop, could be a bit crispier but a crisp is still there. This one’s a 7.9 for me, likely the best in Frederick.

Wanted just a little more crunch on the crust, but can’t go wrong with this pizza.

Good crisp light crust little flop. Good cheese wish I woulda got the spicy sauce

Best in the area. Solid crisp. Signature sauce is money.

A little chewy, good flavor, good crust.

Could be a little tighter. There's flop. But overall very good

Cheese slice

Sauce too sweet but amazing crust

I ordered a cheese pizza with the spicy sauce and it was EXCELLENT. The crust could have been crispier as it was a bit chewy and had a fair amount of flop. If the pizza was cooked just a tad longer it would have easily been in the 9’s. The sauce was robust with a nice zing and the cheese had great flavor.

Good overall pizza. Floppy, but delicious!

Good crust and great crisp. Sauce to cheese ratio is spot on. Signature sauce is by far the best sauce I’ve ever had. This is my favorite pizza place. Good thin crust pizza. Best in Frederick.

So damn good we ordered another pizza and ate it after our first one. Signature sauce is amazing. Entire slice is crispy. Will definitely remember this place. Next time will order with a little more sauce and cheese.