Coalfire Pizza

Delicious. Super quick- sat in & received it within five minutes, literally. Tasty sauce, crunchy outer crust, fluffy inner crust for it being so thin. Real good, will definitely go here again

Real solid. Didn’t really hold its heat for long and I’ll definitely get extra cheese next time. But a solid pie nonetheless.

Would order again. Cheese was delicious. Only downside is that it was delivered cold.

Best pizza in the city

Super thin. Really good flavors, but unfortunately arrived cold. Will try again, dining in

if you’re not ordering a cheese pizza, your score is DISREGARDED. BEST and to my knowledge ONLY coal fired pizza in Chicago. This is the truth, guy. the crisp is there that coal flavor is strong... the cheese is where its set apart. look you’re gonna like this dude.

Good looking pie. The sauce was not great but good. The slice was thin and clean, but wasn't crispy enough. I think Frankie would agree.

Solid slice. Tastes like NY style but with the lightness of a neopolitan. Basil is fresh, great sauce/cheese/ratio. Sauce is good, nothing out of the ordinary. Thin crust

Good pizza. Was hoping for a little more crisp but this is a very good pizza.

Fairly greasy and had a lot of flop but the taste of the cheese and the tang in the sauce make up for it

Absolutely delicious! Cheese slice had the best red sauce I’ve had

terrible service. Pizza was bland.

This pizza was amazing! The crust was the perfect texture and the flavor was delicious! Can’t wait to come back here

Solid coalfire. Sauce could use a bit more kick but the crust was what made this slice. Great Ingredients.

Such a good pie

Honey salami pie the best out there

Alright ya jabronis, one munch everyone knows the mandates. Coalfire. Good sauce, good crust. Fresh ingredients. Solid slice.

First review so I have to go Rookie score. Pepperoni & Ricotta from Coalfire Pizza. EVERYBODY KNOWS THE RULES. Nowhere near traditional Chicago style pizza, more of an East Coast vibe. The char on the crust is a nice touch; however, the crust could’ve been crispier for how thin it is. Garlic and basil isn’t overpowering. It could use a little more mozz near the center but really good overall taste. Solid 8, it’s a review.