Coast to Coast Pizza Company

Seriously good pizza. QuintessentialAmerican pizzeria pie. Grandma was great too.

Easily the best authentic pies being made in the Keys. Crust is firm, with minor flop, but still has a crunch when folded. All ingredients are high quality, and it’s obvious. Worth the stop.

Great service first off!!! Light crispy crust and delicious taste!!

We have a time share in Marathon and come every year. When I seen Dave give this place a 7.7, I had to visit. Well, I think Dave visited on a good day. The girl told me 30 minutes and I was there in 30. My pizza was not that hot and overall, not that great. I would suggest Driftwood or Upper Crust if you're in the area.

Fire Za!!

Great pizza, they have by the slice for lunch, or you can always order by the pie. As of right now it is in my top three best ever, crust is fantastic with hot honey.

Great Pizza!!!

Great taste. Good crunch.

Easily the best pizza in the keys! I drive a half hour just to get a pie from them.

Great char with some flop. Garlic bites are a must!!

Dropped in after a round of golf. Got a Sicilian slice. Sauce is what gives this pizza the big rating. It’s AMAZING! Well cooked. Awesome staff too. Would recommend.

The pizza was amazing! It’s absolutely worth a drive of 50 miles to eat. Great tasting sauce with just a touch of sweetness and nice firm crust! The pizza rivals anything you’re going to find in the northeast. This place is an absolute gem!

The Sicilian Is Unreal. El Jefe is missing out

The grandma’s !