Coast To Coast Pizza Company Marathon

Wish we would have taken a picture sooner. This is CLEARLY the best pizza anywhere around. We’ve had Angelo’s on 9th in Philly and this is on par if not better! Definitely make the stop… and it on can Take is south to Bahia Honda State Park!!!

The sauce was amazing. (Reminded me slightly of Sciortinos’s from New Jersey in the 90’s) Chewy crust… but well cooked throughout.

Good crust sweet sauce

I don't usually write reviews for anything. However, Coast To Coast Pizza Company is great pizza. You would think being in Marathon Florida good pizza would be hard to find but this is our go to every time we visit. The even know how to make a proper cannoli. The Veterans discount is much appreciated and shows they respect our military.

Great flavor, love the sauce. Supper floppy though.

AMOONGUSS

The Sicilian style margherita is by in large the best pizza I’ve had the opportunity to enjoy

Had the 7.7 cheese pie and a chicken bacon ranch pie. Very good. 7.9

Great place, Great Pizza. must go place for pizza lovers when visiting the keys.

I saw the high ratings on this app, so I chose this spot to check out. 1. The slice was very small, as you see in the picture. For a price of 4 bucks plus tax, it could get expensive trying to get full. 2. The dough had a fantastic, unique crispiness that I've never experienced before. Sauce had some sweetness and a very pleasant taste. The cheese they use is one of the best money can buy, Grande, made with whole milk. 3. I was excited to find out that they have one other location, and it just happens to be back in my hometown of Fort Lauderdale. I will be checking them out in the near future!

Love this pizza! Sauce is spot on with seasoning and tang. Crust is almost perfect, just wished it was stretched out a little more to be a thinner finished product. Went with my family standard 4 toppings and just ended up being too heavy but that’s on me. No need to go to another shop. Worth the drive to Marathon. Anthony is a boss and he’s getting it done. Can’t recommend this place enough.

Hands down best pizza in the lower keys if not the whole keys. Will stop and get one anytime i am in marathon. Great crust, amazing overall taste. Levels above any other pizza in the keys by far.

Solid place here. Crisp was perfect and the cheese was on point.

Greatest pizza in the Keys #threegirlsonebite

Honestly I don’t know how it gets much better than this… forgot how much I was missing out on good pizza living in Las Vegas. Maybe coast to coast could be less greasy, but that’s also what makes it so good.. the crust is so amazing in taste and texture. Pizza literally melts in your mouth. New York water machine is a game changer.

Great sauce. Very cheesy. A little under done for my taste. Overall good slice!

Seriously good pizza. QuintessentialAmerican pizzeria pie. Grandma was great too.

Easily the best authentic pies being made in the Keys. Crust is firm, with minor flop, but still has a crunch when folded. All ingredients are high quality, and it’s obvious. Worth the stop.

8.3… taste was great. Good undercarriage. Good crust. Really floppy though and not much crunch.

Great service first off!!! Light crispy crust and delicious taste!!