Colandrea Pizza King (Middletown)

both slices scorching hot but not burnt. Good crisp. a little heavy on the oil for my liking but overall great slices.

Plain slice review. Cheese is good. Nice and piping hot pretty good slice I’d come back for lunch sometime

This thing was as stiff as a board. Zero flop. The cheese was really good, ratios were on point, and it was thin. Sauce had zero seasoning which really hampered the score. Was sweet like spaghetti O's and I like sweet sauce but it was too generic. Crust had a weird texture bc it was over floured and for something with 0 flop it wasn't crisp. Has potential but needs a whole new marinara recipe.

Not greasy at all, a little doughy bur over all good!

It’s really good slice with real flavor. A personal favorite of mine is their Pepperoni Wheels. Slice can be a little doughy but bottom has mice crisp. Great football pie. 7.9 that’s a review

Decent slice, sauce is a bit weak, cheese is overpowering it. Trust the Jersey guys who actually know pizza

Excellent PIzza been going there since 1989

Colandrea Pizza King had an 8.8, and for locals that’s the best slice you’d expect before having to go to Brooklyn. Softer crust. Even browning. No flop to speak of. This is a good slice, and for upstate New York, yeah they keep the title King. 8.3

Good, nothing special 🧔🏻

Fantastic sauce, cheese was perfect, crust was flavorful and light. One of the best slices in the Middletown area.

Best pizza around.

Best cheese pizza in the 845. Great sauce and crispy crust.