Colombo's Cafe & Pastries

We got the scallop and bacon white pizza at Columbo’s and it was amazing. About as perfect of a pizza that I’ve ever tasted

COLOMBO’S CAFE & PASTRIES IN HYANNIS, MA 8.5 CHEDDAR JACK REVIEW #96

First a little floppy gets crunchy as you go. Could have left it in for a little longer

AC 7.1 Crust was good crunch, but overall nothing was special about the pizza. Meh flavor but still good.

This restaurant is a great little Italian joint that will transport you into an Italian cafe. This food here is very good - the pizza however is relatively average. Extravagant crisp but the sauce and cheese leave a lot to be desired. At times the sauce feels like it has potential but these cheese is terribly bland. Fix the cheese and you might have a winner. Great atmosphere though.

Horrible. If you like party pizza, you might really like this because that’s exactly what it tastes like. That’s it, that’s the review. It’s a 3.4 from me.

Easily the best pizza in Cape Cod. Makes the others seem more like lunchables

Thin and crispy. Great options.

crust tasted like garlic knots which was really unique.

Dave’s score is accurate here

Good pizza, could use a little more crunch on the crust, but it’s good pizza

Pizza is bursting with flavor. Crust is not filling, has a great crunch too. Only flaw is the pizza is rather floppy. Highly recommend this place.

Slight bend. Minimal grease. Fire

Minimal to no flop. Slight grease. Ultimately fire.

Alright yeah Colombo‘s Hyannis pizza, sauce is subpar. Its a standard pizza, it’s good but boring. A little too greasy for my liking. The ambience was nice but too crowded to move around. Very pricey for a standard subpar tomato pie

Great pizza! Light with good sauce and cheese. Crust was perfect!

This is a very good pizza for Hyannis and Cape Cod in general...but..prez is a little off. Roni was better simply because the cheese side was bland and needed something more.