Colonna's Pizza

Pie was fresh. Decent amount of flop and grease. Cheese and sauce weren’t even on it. Overall good pizza to have with the fam.

I was really drunk when I ate this so that could’ve affected the score for better or worse.

Authentic New York style Pizza excellent taste and the garlic knots were really good! It averaged out to about $10 a person including a drink which makes it a great value considering the great quality. Our new number one spot!

By far my favorite NY style pizza in CO.

Good cheese blend, crispy yet chewy crust. Good sauce! Some of the other ratings seem too low for how good this was..

If i wanted to wait 40 mins for dogshit pizza i would have put my head up my ass and gone to dominos. Server said they weren’t making food until she changed her mind. Sad! This place lost its luster. Big time

Solid slice! Little greasy and I like the sauce to have a little more bite but still good.

Other scores are overly harsh. Good pizza.

Came to late for the slice only serve during lunch. Got a personal and decent pizza good crunch a little greasy but not to bad.

Not too bad for Colorado but it was just like eating a puddle of grease.

Solid slice, for an entire pie came out to our table right out of the oven. Bet greasy pizza but a solid slice. Soggy in the middle of the pizza but the outer half and crust was nice and crunchy. Very very cheesy pizza.

Good crunch and consistency but Anti flavor. 3.8 frankie