Best Sicilian on all of Long Island and possibly all of NY. The regular is really good too. I’ve been there over 1000 times and they’ve never disappointed me.
donteatshittyfood2/21/21, 5:18 p.m.
Two regular slices (forgot to take pic) looked pretty good. Cheese was sliding off a bit & it wasn’t even that hot. Sauce was better than some other places, but that’s about it. It’s a good regular slice.
jarettdesanti1/22/21, 2:45 a.m.
Colosseo Pizza & Restaurant Rating - 8.6 Excellent pizza. Lots of cheese and sauce. Good dough. 👌
tony.o1/1/21, 9:10 p.m.
Hmm... First review of the new year and after a long layoff of reviews.. The sauce hits you off the bat with a hint of sweetness. The cheese and crust are a non factor..
pmw12/13/20, 9:50 p.m.
Regular - 8.5 outstanding slice. Perfect crust, on the fluffier side but great. Greasy but not too greasy, the cheese is also top notch. Sauce is great and healthy portion without flopping too much. Sauce is what keeps it out of the 9s. Could’ve used a little less oregano but still great. Pepperoni- 8.8 outstanding, real pepperoni. Not that processed stuff. Greased up from the pep. One small nit is that the pizza cold / reheated doesn’t maintain its value as well.
tgipizza.111/21/20, 11:26 p.m.
Really good football pizza! Sauce is solid a tad greasy. No flop
wurmlife10/2/20, 5:30 p.m.
Rainy Friday coming at you live at Colosseo. Regular slice, flopped like the New York giants, but the crunch was on point, sauce was alright. 6.4 that’s a review
sam.kleinick7/11/20, 11:48 p.m.
I’m a city snob, but it could’ve been crispier. Very greasy and a ton of flop. That said the sauce is great!
juan.rivera24/29/20, 12:55 a.m.
people really brag about this place out here and it's really good but something about it is missing.... it's a really good slice but something is keeping it from being over an 8...
jay.marine2/18/20, 10:55 p.m.
This review is gonna break my heart, but I gotta keep it real for the peeps lol. So I’ve been coming here for DECADES, literally. Today I reminded myself why I never just get a regular slice. Very doughy... no crisp whatsoever. Everything tasted just average. Having said that, this place is one of my favorites spots because their Sicilian, stuffed, white, buffalo chicken, and their toppings are outrageously good... but as we know, we only score the gold standard here. Ay oh... I don’t make the rules, I just play by them 🤷🏻♂️ I recommend definitely coming here and getting ANYTHING else, you won’t regret it. Boom, that’s a review. Keepin it real... 😉
justin.macarthur2/18/20, 8:51 p.m.
extra floppy crust had a great taste needed to be crisper. def worth a stop if your near by
matthew.petrocelli2/16/20, 10:26 p.m.
Best pizza in Shelton by a long shot and I think better than Roseland or anywhere else in the valley. Sauce has a tang but a good tang. Crust is tasty with just enough char. Cheese is good quality and doesn’t make a lot of grease. This is a thin cross between bar style and apizza. The only negative is one large is easily taken down by two people.
milo.scarpone2/8/20, 5:41 p.m.
I loved the Fresh marinated mushrooms, the great crisp on the pizza overall an amazing slice.
robert.singer22/5/20, 8:48 p.m.
Delicious and authentic slice. The Sicilian is even better (8.5)...
pizzadoctor.1/14/20, 8:51 p.m.
Good pizza but almost burned my face with the grease coming from the cheese. Oily mcoil over here but nevertheless very good combination of flavors going on. This place looks just like branchinellis which is right down the block and in my opinion better because not as oily therefore it gets .3 points lower. Tighten that shit up and score goes up
kristopher.lee12/24/19, 5:14 p.m.
Garbage, watered down sauce, floppy AF, no taste... like El Prez says TRASH