Colosseo Pizzeria & Restaurant

Great flavor, NICE crisp crust, but thin enough at the end for a little flop. I will be back

A very nice slice! Great fresh flavor and nice crispy crust. I’d definitely eat here again! Nice decor inside too. You can take your wife here. NOTE: the place is called Mamma Lilla now! Proprietor is from Brooklyn. Has made pizzas for 30 years and it shows. Go get you some!

Giving it a 6.8, pizza alone would have been a 6.5...but the lady was super nice and friendly. Ps. It’s called Mamma Lilla now.

Okay Frankie. Really tasty cheese , not much sauce. Definitely floppy , yet not too messy. Solid crispness , and good crust.

Great pizza. It's worth going out of the way for. My problem with all my reviews is I'm basing these all on the Florida curve since good pizza around here is almost impossible to find . For all I know this could be average elsewhere

Ok Frankie. Made with a lot of love. But crazy flop. A little to cheesy, a little greasy. Over all a good tasting slice but not my cup of tea. I like a good crunch. 6.5.

No flop, but sauce isn’t tangy. Good standard slice. I’m told Tuesday and Thursday is the time to be there so I will give a second chance. Probably the best pizza in the area for cheese. Lasagna pizza is good 8.1, garlic knots and bread is around 8.2.

The best pizza on long island