Colosseum New York Pizza

Been twice now in my quest to find BayArea's best...(Forgot the photo first time) I would equate this to Slice of NY which as far as my southbay experiences go...these are the best for NY style so far down here (not a lot of options) and I'm sure many NY natives would have some gripes. I've sampled both cheese and pep, Pep is little greasy cheese is a little lacking in flavor as the other reviews state. I found undercarriage crisp/flop depends on who heats up your slice.

Decent slice. Good crisp, a little greasy for my taste, no flop, cheese was okay and the sauce was lacking. Overall would come back if I was in the area but wouldn’t go out of my way.

Nice sauce and cheese ratio. It’s floppy and the bottom ain’t crispy but it ain’t soggy. Fresh ingredients tho good shit.

Definitely a New York style place but the pizza is just not that impressive. Nothing really stands out with the pie. Decent under carriage but crust is just too doughy. The cheese doesn’t have much flavor and neither does the sauce. Herbs are a nice touch though.

Best NY style pizza I've found in the Bay Area. Tastes like home. Good balance of crunch and flop, good sauce, crust is perfect.

I did add a little garlic and oregano to it (just my go to move )but they have solid slices barely any flop and crispy crust pretty good I would drive 30 to 45 mins for this slice

Ordered a meat lovers and must say was a solid pizza. Great sauce and tasty crust. Just a bit floppy.

Great pizza! Excellent thin crispy crust, great cheese and solid sauce. You can’t go wrong and the atmosphere is perfect. It’s what you want from a pizza joint.

Solid football pizza. Crust is a little doughy. Good tang.

Cheese Pizza 7.4- Great crisp good cheese flavor good sauce. Pepperoni 8.1- Fantastic pepperoni, great flavor and crisp. Must have here.

Great pizza... a little greasy, good sauce and good cheese. I would have liked a little more crisp. I am not sure how it compares to actual New York style pizza, but for California this good pizza. In the area I live in it is hard to find a good pizza place. I will definitely be ordering again!

Closest thing to a NY slice in South Bay. Pricey

For California, this is about as good as you’re gonna get for pizza. It’s not Pizzeria Regina in the North End of Boston level, ( or Santarpios) or Johns of Bleecker Street in NYC. But for the Bay Area of Northern California, it’s a pretty decent pie. The review reflects pizza scoring I’ve done for all pizza I’ve had throughout the US & Canada. Solid pizza! Oh and the neon NY Giants light in the window has GOT to go! This place is my new go to for pizza

It’s greasy as shit but it’s literally the best NY pizza we have in the area. The people are nice. The place stays open late. They even have a real New Yorker running the place. I’d like to give it a higher grade because they’re the only authentic place in the area, and it’s far and away the best pizza place in the area. But, I think this is where it stacks up.