Columbia Inn

We were super hesitant about the first look. Looked very cracker like. But it was soft, but firm with a nice crunch on the crust. Sweet sauce. Portnoy must have been cooked upon walking in, with that score

Could have been higher but took it home (30 min drive) and was not hot by than… still amazing flavor

Very thin, not bad decent

Thiny thin- great pie atmosphere is great, wouldn’t think with the area it is in! I was about to give it a 7.9 but had a 2nd slice it is a 8.1 for sure

Thin n crispy!

Was so hyped to try this but I didn’t get the hype. Pizza is good but not an 8.7. I’m sorry.

Undercarriage was raw. Too thin. Overhyped

The thinnest pizza ever .. I wasnt sure id love it this thing but wow. Perfect crisp and perfect amount of sauce and cheese

Extremely thin bar pie here. Great zing in the sauce that I enjoyed. Nice little place off the highway to enjoy a good meal or a beer at the bar. Another one well worth the drive

Got a regular cheese and the bar pie. Both were good, liked the sauce a lot. Would get it again but could definitely eat 6 total pies. Don’t come hungry.

Taste was immaculate. Usually I’m not a thin pizza kind of guy, but this one was amazing. A pizza like no other. One of a kind for sure

Worst experience and pizza of my life

Hello Zeke. We’re in Montville NJ today. Thinnest slice I’ve ever had. Cheese and sauce phenomenal, almost like biting into a big cracker. No flop. No crumbs. My favorite thin slices remain Ralph’s and Chitch’s, so I can’t rate this above them on principle.

Bandits very impressed. Paper thin crust. High quality ingredients. Well constructed sauce. Only criticism is slightly under filling. Dave got this one spot on. Bandit 1: 8.7 Bandit 2: 8.7 Bandit 3: 8.7 Columbia Inn, you can come on over.