Columbia Inn

Extremely thin bar pie here. Great zing in the sauce that I enjoyed. Nice little place off the highway to enjoy a good meal or a beer at the bar. Another one well worth the drive

Got a regular cheese and the bar pie. Both were good, liked the sauce a lot. Would get it again but could definitely eat 6 total pies. Don’t come hungry.

Taste was immaculate. Usually I’m not a thin pizza kind of guy, but this one was amazing. A pizza like no other. One of a kind for sure

Worst experience and pizza of my life

Hello Zeke. We’re in Montville NJ today. Thinnest slice I’ve ever had. Cheese and sauce phenomenal, almost like biting into a big cracker. No flop. No crumbs. My favorite thin slices remain Ralph’s and Chitch’s, so I can’t rate this above them on principle.

Bandits very impressed. Paper thin crust. High quality ingredients. Well constructed sauce. Only criticism is slightly under filling. Dave got this one spot on. Bandit 1: 8.7 Bandit 2: 8.7 Bandit 3: 8.7 Columbia Inn, you can come on over.

Literally the thinnest pizza I’ve had in my life. Very crispy, excellent sauce and wonderful cheese. Only criticism is the crust, because it should be bigger since it was so good. The only reason it’s not a nine is because there are other places that I liked even more.

Super thin pizza. Great taste but really thin. One person could eat a large pie easily. Good crisp also. Glad I stopped but was still hungry after splitting a large with my son.

Pizza was all right, the crust was super thin, thin like a tortilla, but only issue was it was lacking a lot of sauce, and the pie was very very dry. Cheese was OK tasted kind of like a heated up pizza.

Paper thin pizza right here, but I don’t mind that at all. I like this style very much actually. 8.2 is an honest score. It’s deserving of an 8… place is really an Italian restaurant with a full menu. Has a nice big bar… old decor.. cool spot. Worth a visit.

Struggle to see why this was an 8.7 by Dave. Absolutely no sauce, half the slices are dry. Thin and cheese is delicious, but needs a lot of work to be in the high 8’s. Tasty thin crust, but not mind blowing. Typical overscoring by the pizza “king” himself 😅

Only thing lacking this pizza is the sauce. I didn’t find it very flavorful but that may be because it is the thinnest pizza I’ve ever had. This pizza has most things going for it 🍕

One of Dave’s highest ranked pizza places… thought it was pretty good and definitely worth a try. The cheese and sauce were super fresh and were excellent. However the pizza crust, although tasted good could not be more thin - legit as thin as paper. You could eat 3 full pies and still be hungry.

Great pie!

Completely shocked this made the 8s. It’s super thin. Holds up well. Has almost no sauce and didn’t really have much taste either. I have gone to a bunch of places before and after portnoy. Almost every reco has been great. This was a real miss. Buddy I was with felt the same. Lacking taste, sauce and character. Crust and body holds up well. Ingredients taste either cheap or non existent. Sadly shocked.

I feel Dave over scored it...Good sauce and cheese combo. The crust was great, but I've tasted dozens of pizzas like this. If it wasn't for the unique crust, I'd given it high 7's. But all an all it's a good pie. For reference, the crust is about as thin as a tortilla, and someone could probably eat the whole thing by themselves. The wife and I ate it all within 5 mins

You can tell the cheese is quality. Loved the crunch. From Buffalo NY came here because of El Prez!

Good bar pizza. Not knock you socks off