7,736 views•1,133 likes
baldeagles8/9/20, 5:06 p.m.
Very Good! If you like thin crust pizza, this is the place. Overall the pizza had a great taste both sauce and cheese had very good flavor to it.
pizzapro697/22/20, 10:26 p.m.
Lived up to the hype. Sauce is extremely good. If you like thin pizza then this shit is for you. Perfect crisp
francisco.rivera17/19/20, 12:37 a.m.
Tried the pizza at Columbia Inn and loved it! Super thin and crispy. Drove 45 minutes to try it out and definitely will be back. @stoolpresidente thanks for the review! Great spot.
kevin.price7/19/20, 12:01 a.m.
I was worried thinking these high scores and Dave was done in by it too. It was cooked well and the cheese and the sauce weren’t to bad but the crust lacked the taste to be in that kind of talks. I’m not mad, just disappointed. Shoulda stayed in philly....
john.tria7/17/20, 12:01 a.m.
This pizza is such a snack. I could easily eat a whole pie on my own. Ultra thin crust almost like a thin flat bread. 0 flop. The cheese and sauce are super unique tasting
tiki.pete7/16/20, 2:37 a.m.
This might be the best pizza I've ever had. I think this will be hard to beat. I'd give it a 10, but I'm leaving room for hopeful growth!
tbach857/12/20, 11:01 p.m.
Thin and crispy. Greasy though. A lot of cheese for a thin crust pizza. Good pie though.
nicky.steccino7/12/20, 7:32 p.m.
Pretty good pizza. Bonus points because the manager (same guy from the barstool video) was handing out free slices while people wait & of course the "God bless America" on the box. The Marguerita & Bianca were both tasty, wondering how a buffalo chx or other heavy toppings would hold up. Definitely worth the drive.
bronx161street7/12/20, 2:53 p.m.
There was one thing missing from the middle to the tip of each slice, Sauce! This means when the cook used the ladle to spread the sauce it was spread too think in the middle of the pie. I usually ask for light or very little cheese on every pie no matter what the place, this pie did not need that instruction. Not an 8.7, I will visit again asking for extra sauce.
25 views•2 likes
jimmy.villari7/11/20, 8:33 p.m.
Gotta be the thinnest pizza I’ve ever had. If thin and crispy bar pie is your jam, this will not disappoint
paulie.pizza7/11/20, 12:33 a.m.
Great thin crust pizza. Perfect ratio across the board. Crispy outer crust but not as much on the dough. It felt just how a matzoh pizza should taste. Worth a trip.
anthonypizzi7/11/20, 12:02 a.m.
Floury bottom, thin crust how i like it but tasteless. Sauce is sweet and tangy; they don’t add too much cheese which is good. Not bad pizza, just not pizza I would run for at any given notice. More like, once a year you go with friends or family to drink at the bar and order a pizza over conversation. After going there, I always leave disappointed because of the lack of flavor; your leaving full but not satisfied hence why I’m there once a year. Since Dave ranked Star Tavern 7.2, I’m going 6.4. Star Tavern has been in the game longer and having been a customer at Star Tavern and Columbia Inn for almost 20 years now, there is no comparison and the difference in taste is very distinct; Star Tavern has flavor. If you’re in the neighborhood give Columbia Inn a try, you might like it!