Community Pie - Downtown

I normally try to rate pizza based on cheese, margarita, or something in the cheese ballpark. This place had a slice called the “Demarco” it is red sauce, mozzarella, Brooklyn mozzarella, and Fresh Basil. Really good, sauce was on point, cheese was great, and the crust was so crispy. Nearly zero flop and it was a huge piece.

Good taste. Crust was a little floppy

Best pizza in all TN!! Hands down!! If you can’t get New Haven or anything from the NE then THIS IS IT!!! amazing pizza!!

Just can’t get much better

Good undercarriage, lots of flop. The crust has a cardboard flavor to it, the cheese is pretty good, and the sauce is really good. On mine, they barely put any sauce and too much cheese. Fresh ingredients.

I’ve been here before and had a great experience with a much higher score. Made a return visit today and was highly disappointed. . . . Chewy crust, little toppings, not crisp.

Overall good pizza. Little greasy, crust ends had good crisp. Definitely a floppy NY Slice. I could easily eat this pizza over and over. Also tried a slice of Detroit style. Very hearty thick crust slice. That could have used a little more sauce for my taste. But still decent. Give that a 7.1

Finally. Found what is likely the best pizza in the ‘Nooga. Thin and crispy. The cheese and sauce each hit the mark. Plus, the added Parmesan provided is in chunks and not saw dust. Glad this slice wraps up my evening. 🍕🍕🍕

The cheese made the pie

Thin, crispy, and no flop! Great undercarriage and tasty crust. Only downside was they were light on the sauce but overall great pizza. Definitely recommend!

We had a split pizza between the Melrose and the BBQ chicken. Both were phenomenal but the melrose is a MUST have. It is the best pizza I have ever eaten. The BBQ chicken lacked a bit of sauce to me

Solid

Crispy undercarriage and crust, zero flop, zesty sauce. Best pizza in Chattanooga.

Bomb . Com

Good amount of cheese and crisp for it being a NY style. It was lacking pepperoni and the sauce a bit on the tangy side. It’s one of the better NY style that I can remember.

Good crust and toppings but a bit floppy

Delicious slices, had to go back and get a whole pie of the roasted mushroom, pretty good. It would of made the 8’s if the crust wasn’t so hard to chew.

Been looking for some good NY Style Pizza in the Chattanooga area. This was the best so far. Great crust and fresh ingredients.

Solid crisp. Good flavor with very little flop. Good solid NY style pizza.

Totally Portnoy’s style (light with crunch). I’d probably prefer more sauce. Solid slice tho!

Thin. Spicy pepperoni. Very good