Conestoga Style Pizza

This is a pretty basic slice, essentially what you’d expect from pizza in this area. The cheese, sauce, and crust are all mediocre. I probably won’t come back here, but I guess it served its purpose as pizza to eat during the Super Bowl.

A little flop. That American Greek style. Not my favorite style but you can eat a ton of this pizza. Pretty good.

BEST PIZZA ON THE MAIN LINE. PERIOD. Ignore any reviews talking about how their slices are bad. Conestoga is NOT a joint for slices. They only make one or two slice pies a day so it’s not their thing. Don’t be cheap and get a whole pie. Little bit of flop. Cheese to sauce ratio is a little out of whack but the sauce is on point and has a good, robust flavor; maybe even a little bite to it. Probably one of the oldest pizza joints on the Main Line and has been around that long for good reason. Give it a shot; it won’t disappoint.

Good Pizza a little doughy, good sauce cheese

The naked pizza like this for 41 years

This is one of the worst slices I have ever had. Sauce to cheese ratio was way off, way too much cheese. Crust was almost indistinguishable from the rest of the pizza. Pizza had almost no taste. Do not recommend.

If you like floppy pizza, this is the floppiest pizza on the planet. It droops down like a pair of granny boobs

Not terrible but not a ton of flavor. 6.1