Coniglio's Old Fashioned

Crispy yet airy crust for grandma pie. Cheese basil and sauce were excellent. A must try. Well done!!

This crust!!! The crisp, the dough, the cook, the golden brownness and the under carriage. On top of the salty, creamy cheese, and the hearty, aromatic sauce, this pie is legit and cooked perfectly!

Solid taste with a satisfyingly airy crust that pushes it into the 8s.

Had the grandma the sauce and crust were outstanding. Also the semolina bread is awesome. The roast pork sandwich was delicious as well. I’ll be back to try some other pies

Nothing special, although the sauce and the place itself were very unique.

Great pizza, really cool place. Nino is an OG and I think bc of that Dave over rated this spot a bit. Crust was unbelievable and surprisingly little flop for how many ingredients were on this absolute unit of a pizza. 7.9

Very very good. Love the ingredients, fresh tomatoes cheese and nice crust. Neopolitan-New York style as I call it. Great choice if in the area.

Expecting more flavor. I liked the crisp crust, but the cheese and sauce were lacking.

Meatball and ricotta pie - outstanding crust, no flop , very tasty . Needed a little salt but the best of the area !

Love this place. Vibe is fire. Feels like Italy inside. Recommend a sit down and enjoy. Ingredients are clearly fresh and they know their way around a pizza . Would try other types of pies here. Pies only. Will be back

Crust was fantastic. Cheese was fresh and tasty, sauce tasted cooked and more of a Sicilian style which held it back from 9 territory. Fantastic pizza though, would come back if I’m in the area. Bonus: The Caesar salad was a 10/10

No bad at all. I really like the cheese. The dough was kinda like Neapolitan style but it was crispy. The dough did taste like the oven needed to be cleaned. Sauce needed more garlic.

Amazing pie and great crust/crunch! Pair it with an old fashion Coke, can’t go wrong.

Where to start.. excellent service inside. Provided is w a complimentary pastry. Now to the pizza, forget about it, amazing Brooklyn style Margherita. Crunchy crust… the dough is phenomenal. Sauce… home run, must stop. Great atmosphere. 🍕🤌🏽

Love the sauce. Pepperoni ok. Crust is delicious.

Very good