Bland crust. Good cheese. Bland sauce. Chewy not crispy.
tony.o4/18/21, 9:15 p.m.
Very good pizza! Crispy crust, nice sauce and good cheese. If you include the scene in the pizza parlor and the excellent service it’s an 8+ pizza. If you are scoring on the pizza alone it’s a 7.9. If I lived in the area would I make a weekly trip her for a pie and bud heavys- Absolutely!
john.peppelman4/11/21, 2:54 a.m.
We Enjoyed a plain + pepperoni and onion + sausage onion and roasted red pepper pies. Very Flavorful and crispy. Nice balance of cheese and sauce. I liked The plain the best. We drove from Blue Bell to try it based on Dave’s video and all the reviews.We will be back as it was worth the trip. The staff was attentive and nice to chat with especially cynthia. Was fun to then walk around Princeton for dessert and more beverages.
leo.hernandez4/9/21, 1:22 a.m.
Very thin but crunchy crust. The crust is even a little burnt so you get the flavor. The sauce is juicy and fresh. Flavor from beginning to end
mike.herrick14/6/21, 6:48 p.m.
First ever 9 rating I’ve ever gave. Fantastic all around. Great sauce, cheese wasn’t too overpowering, little grease and cooked to perfection on a thin crust. Not too thin, not too doughy.. just perfect.
brian.pawling4/2/21, 9:18 p.m.
Great crisp to the crust and liked the sauce flavor. A little greasy but knew that going in. Great atmosphere inside...classic bar pizza.
lizzie.mayer3/31/21, 2:20 p.m.
Great traditional New Jersey pizza! Thin, cheesy, delicious! The crust was more like a cracker though.
kelly.s13/14/21, 12:28 a.m.
Best pizza in NJ! And I've been to Dave's 9's and high 8's around me
robert.re2/28/21, 12:22 a.m.
Went here based on Dave’s review slightly better than avg but not spectacular by any means. Crust kinda crackerish if that makes sense like a matza cracker pretty much bar pie jmho
mikeymike3d932/27/21, 1:07 a.m.
Average pizza and not worth the wait outside while they prepare your order to eat inside. Considerable flop, much virtue signaling.
itsjustjohn132/27/21, 1:05 a.m.
Good pizza, crunchy crust and good amount of cheese. Sauce could be better. Not worth the hassle though of having to wait outside while your pizza cooks to just be inside
ayhanca2/26/21, 9:59 p.m.
Amazing crust, great service, it was little greasy and salty for me but overall a very good pizza.
joe.carchia2/26/21, 9:35 p.m.
Not sure what all hype is about. It was good, but I was expecting spectacular.
sds52192/22/21, 8:34 p.m.
Very crispy with excellent flavor. However, it’s very greasy so if you avoid places like that then this pizza isn’t for you.
shaun.gaffney2/21/21, 1:33 a.m.
Pretty good Jersey slice. Was expecting a little more based on all the reviews, but I can see why people enjoy it so much. Good pizza any way you look at it.