Conte's Pizza

it was good but not that good

Good pizza, minimal undercarriage very good flavor.

Bad service long wait Pepperonis stacked together/too thick Plastic tasting cheese

4/3/26

Nice crisp, tasty sauce and cheese but the crust didn't have much seasoning. Still enjoyed it

Unique pizza. Sauce is very tomato-y. The cheese has a gnarly tang. Crust is firm but light. Solid za for sure!

Great sauce to cheese ratio.

Really good pie definitely worth the hype. Crispy on the edges and perfect in the middle. Sausage was excellent as well.

Thin and crispy! Excellent pie.

Very good Pizza. Fairly light, with great crust and no flop. Meatballs are also great.

Very good! Possibly a bit over hyped…?? But certainly great pizza. The bread tasted like matzah?!?

So I normally I get just plain. But I was with friends. I can tell this place is top notch! One of the best stops get. Great sauce and ingredients and perfect cook!!

Really fucking good pizza. Not much crunch throughout the slice though. The undercarriage has lots of flour and it comes off on the fingertips a little bit. This crust is gas though, it tastes like matzah. Sauce is very sweet, adds some nice tang there. Overall, needs more crunch and less sauce imo. Definitely up there in NJ’s pizza rankings, but not on the Mount Rushmore.

Amazing taste, incredible crisp, a little thiccer than I’d like but not enough to tank the score. Understandable why there was a 45 min wait

Banging

Okay, but not in the 8’s. Too much cheese, floppy and the classic flavorless, dry NJ crust. Wood or coal fire would probably improve it

Slightly disappointed, the reviews made it seem like this pizza was elite but I think it was just good not great.

Whenever we are near one of days reviews, my son who plays baseball, always likes to check it out. This place was legit.

Love this place, so cool. Old school hangout vibe in a beautiful town. Place was PACKED. Pizza was GOOD. Must try. Reminded me of Teddy’s in Elmont.