Corleone's Old Fashion Tomato Pie & Pizza

Brooklyn slice is absolutely incredible. Thin and crispy and the sauce has plenty of cake. Some of the best sauce I’ve ever had. It’s sweeter. Great cheese blend. Excellent excellent above average slice

Simply amazing. All of it. Everytime.

I did these guys wrong by getting the slice rather than the full pie, because it was really good but probably would've been an even higher score with the pill pie. Very good Sicilian.

#262 I feel like I’m gonna get whacked for this review. But I’m sorry it just was not a good slice. Very cold even though they said it just came out. Puddle of grease in the center. Crust not good. Cheese not good. No crisp. Only thing saving this was the sauce had a nice flavor and tang.

Great pizza ..the tomato pie I'd give 7.2

This is a review of their tomato pie (I see the other reviews are for the pizza). It’s fantastic. Light and sweet like Trenton-style tomato pie should be. The crust, which is a little dry, prevents it from entering the 9s. Bonus: also had the vodka penne pizza, which is as creamy and cheesy as you’d expect. It’s great, but I’d welcome a little more crispiness. 8.6 on that.

0 flop but greasy. Has a Parmesan cheese flavor but sweet. Good football pizza

Solid slice, could’ve gotten a higher score if the sauce wasn’t so sweet. The hot pepper flakes mellow it though.

Really solid

The Godfather would be proud. Cheese is great, sauce is a bit sweet, maybe more than I would normally want. Solid quality, unfortunately i saw no mobster's in this pizzeria during my experience.