Cosimo & Johnny’s Pizzeria

Very underrated, very old school. This is exactly what I expect from a NY style plain cheese pizza slice, great cheese, paper thin crispy crust, a bold sweet flavorful sauce, no flop, great undercarriage. Easily the best in Eastchester.

Old school pizza options - cash only. Best pizza in Eastchester, without a doubt. Great crunch, and even better sauce.

Solid slice! The crust is perfectly baked ( not too crunchy, not too soft). The cornmeal on the bottom adds another layer of flavor. Sauce is above average. Sausage slices and chicken parm slices are excellent. Broccoli Rabe calzone is outstanding.

Love the crust. Super thin and crispy, with what I think was a light corn meal dusting on the bottom adding to the crisp. Cheese was good and not overwhelming in amount, which I like. Sauce was the weak link, to the extent this slice has one. Not bad, but a tiny bit light on flavor.

1 cheese slice and a Snapple, 12:55pm on a Friday, $5.25 Pros: Thin slice, nice sandy dusting on undercarriage, good flavor, crispy crust Cons: Lot of flop, little greasy but not too bad Verdict: A nice tasting, slightly above average slice

Thin. Light. No flop. Very greasy. Pretty good taste overall. Decent crunch.

Very good, get the sausage.

Good crust no taste sauce , to much grated cheese

Good pizza, some Westchester flop, and a bit greasy. 7.1 maybe a bit hi but that's my review.

Great taste, loved the crust, but incredibly greasy and floppy. Calzone was very legitimate though.

Pizza was medium thickness, cheese was good and there was lots of it. Crust and sauce were nothing tow rite home about

Thin and crispy. Not very tasty. Sauce and cheese just eh. Grease ball! Reputation has been ruined. It was recommended to me by a friend who said “it is better than Johnnys Pizzeria.” I am now no longer associated with this friend.

The whole pie is better than the individual slice, but not bad.

Great slice overall. They are bringing quality Bronx pizza to Westchester county. Sausage slice would have scored higher. Highly recommend this place