Cosmo's Pizza

Decided to wax nostalgic and bring our pre-teen by Cosmo’s tonight. We didn’t even know they weren’t on The Hill anymore. Always a respectable slice. Try them!

Alright frankie, after a few beers, its a solid 7.3. Sober, a good 6.7. Not a bad pie, good for the price. One bite

You pay for what you get. Is a slice gonna blow your balls off? No, but it’s good for a cheap and tasty meal.

Meh, not a lot of flavor

One nibble everyone knows the law. Had high hopes but the cheese let me down. Sausage also eh

It’s a good slice that’s consistently prepared. It’s NY style and always fresh and delicious and hard to find in Colorado. If your a pizza fan I give it a OneBite score of 7.7 it’s a very good slice and is also great at all locations I have had it. Staff is always on point also!

Not a bad slice at all. Def a football pizza, plenty of flop. Crust is perfect, a little doughy with crisp.

Thin crust, heavy flop, still a solid drunk slice

For a college centric pizza joint this place is pretty Good. Nice light crust big ass slice stayed straight as an arrow. No Boulder flop! Only thing keeping it from the 7s is a so so sauce

Crust needs a major upgrade

This is trash pizza, sauce taste like its the cheapest sauce they could by from a can, the cheese miiiiiiight be plastic and the crust has no flavor and it’s brutal, who ever gave this place a 7 is an incompetent swine.