Cosmo's Pizza

Overly sweet sauce, not great cheese and bland sausage

The picture is just for attention because no attention is needed for cosmos pizza as of current. To premise this id like to say cosmos use to be one of my favorites. I had a pizza from them yesterday and it was probably one of the worst pies I’ve ever had. It was under cooked, too saucey, extremely late on the pick up time. It was so bad that im never coming here again. I feel bad writing this because I use to love this place.

Sauce is excellent. No flop. Cheese is decent. Pizza was properly cooked. Not a bad option for NY style pizza in Fort Collins.

Shit pizza. Tastes like cardboard and have gotten many undercooked pizza. Definitely not recommend

Jake rates Cosmos a 7.5 Frankie

It’s national pizza day. I’m a little underwhelmed with Cosmos pizza. Usually they are pretty good but my pizza was a little undercooked. The dough wasn’t crispy but the cheese and sauce was completely up to standards. Can’t go wrong!

Extra big slices - lots of flip. All in all a great stop on our part!

Overrated pizza here folks. Enjoyable if 8/10 drunk