Costco

not crispy, lots of flop, really doughy, tastes good, hot cheese

When I think Costco pizza, I think of the in house, greasy slices, served on a paper plate, covered with foil. Something about ordering your own pie sets this pizza apart. This was cooked to perfection - solid cheese to sauce ratio. Heavy pepperoni but that’s what you want when you opt for the roni. It is a doughier option but isn’t undercooked by any means - just enough chew to tie everything together. This ranks on the top of the big 3 scale - Papa Js, Dominos, Pizza Hut. Especially at the price point and the speedy preparation, definitely an option to keep at the front of mind when craving a slice… or 4.

It’s time someone said it. The pizza is fresh. The ingredients are quality. This is a fine pizza. This is not a thin pizza with a lot of crunch, but rather a more floppy pizza with great taste. I would choose this pizza over some dedicated pizza places. Credit where credit is due. There is no better deal than a solid Costco pie.

Doughy 0 crisp, lots of cheese, decent flavor for mass produced pizza

Was sitting in heat lamp so it’s not too fresh. Regardless, tastes below average. Can’t beat that price though

If you’re into value, this is for you. Extremely oily! Gargantuan flop! Good taste, beats chain pizza but not by much. If you like quantity over quality, this is for you!

Meant for the Rochester NY Costco. Really crappy pizza

As underrated as they come. The most distinctive slice on earth. It is always the same too so as dependable as knowing diners and drive ins will be on food network when nothing else is on the tube. This also far exceeds your chain pizza. It’s floppy and cheesy but never drips. You are kidding yourself if you don’t appreciate this.

What you would expect from a Costco Pizza not world class but when you’re hungry it’s good especially at its price.

Great tasting cheese! On the lily side. Crust is above average😋

If you’re hungry and have $2

Alright Frankie, Costco’s pizza was def above average, much better than any pizza from St. Louis

While the Costco I got my pie from was in Virginia as opposed to Jersey, I can safely say Dave missed by a mile on this one. Now don’t get me wrong, I can understand how one could not be a fan of Costco’s pizza. What I can’t fathom is how you give Costco a 1.9 while giving Chuck-E-Cheese a 6. With all that being said, Costco pizza has the flavor and the cheesey deliciousness we all want from a solid pie. The undercarriage however is pretty much an atrocity. It’s floppy, cardboardy and one mess of a slice. Very Little Caesar’s-esque in taste with a lot more sog and flop underneath. Be that as it may, the flavor you get from the cheese and sauce is surprising for a Wholesale store like Costco. While it isn’t anything special, I’d definitely eat Costco pizza again, especially during football season as this is quintessential football pizza. It’s solid pizza and that’s not something I think should be considered a hot take. 6.7 lock it in.

Its what you'd expect, but good if you need to fill up for cheap and your in a pinch

Sad presentation. Looks like someone sat on it before it was served. Perfect size for a fold, but it sits in a pool of grease which is not ideal. Mostly grease with a side of pizza. Cheese tastes like skim milk mozzarella. Their crust is soft, but gets mopped with grease. Pepperonis have zero charm. No crisp, just sad and floppy. Overall, a casual pizza that makes a night sad.

Nice and doughy good amount of chesse just no taste of sauce

Filling but Seriously, No