Costello's Pizzeria & Wings

Garbage

Lot of sauce but pretty decent flavor. Very sweet. Lotta flop action

A large slice indeed. Great flavor on the sauce, and solid crunch on the crust. Despite the size, it is a thin and crushable slice, getting near boardwalk-style territory. Not rating it, but their buffalo chicken slice has a sweet flavor to it.

Really nothing special at all. I don’t know why they say that their the town favorite. Good just to get the job done.

Check out this 🍕review and more on my Instagram @big_lou_approved

Sauce was the greatest part. Undercooked, very doughy. Was hoping it would be better.

Basic pie, dough a bit chewy, to muck cheese

Cheese was okay, sauce was nothing to write home to mom about, really doughy. Would be better after some booze fueled night.

Get it fresh outta the oven!!

On a family vacation - I expected much better.

Best in the plaza...only in the plaza.

Good football pizza goooo eagles!!