Alright Frankie… I don't want to hate too much because the restaurant is super cool and maybe the margherita pizza isn't my thing, but I was pretty disappointed by it. I was expecting some bomb pizza from the reviews and pics and it was just… eh. It didn't taste bad, in fact, some of the bites I had were heavenly, but overall it just wasn't great. Maybe it was the sauce, maybe it was the lack of a lot of cheese, idk. 6.4 but I'd like to come back and get something else.
eman.huling6/18/21, 11:46 p.m.
Some of the best pizza we’ve had in Clearwater. Got the 4 cheese, half with pepperoni.
stevenboe2275/30/21, 12:19 a.m.
Fresh as fuck, dope as fuck, crisp, good burn bubbles, great service!!
floridascott5/24/21, 6:32 p.m.
Clearwater area pizza review. This place has many good reviews, with 59 people and an average rating of 7.9. Two different people recommended this place to me at work. 1. This is a Margherita style pizza with the fresh basil. My first review of one this style. 2. Personally not a fan of having one bite with lots of cheese and then 1 bite of all sauce, better when it's all uniform. 3. On the reviews they were raving about it's delicious ingredients, but I did not think of it much more than pretty good. The coal fired dough was top of the line and made to perfection. 4. From watching Dave from barstool pizza reviews, he most likely would say it is the type of pizza that you would order in fine dining with a glass of wine. 5. My rating is 7.1
tommyyg5/19/21, 4:02 p.m.
Ok...this is really really good pizza...Margarita style. Lots of flavor and very fresh. One of the best in the area!! I’ll be back!
matt.gay15/7/21, 6:35 p.m.
Good undercarriage. Sweet sauce. The classic margherita is $12 for a large. Lots of bubbles in the crust. Overall 7.8, solid pizza in Clearwater!
dylan.scuderi4/14/21, 1:37 a.m.
Great pizza! Probably the best in Clearwater! Also very nice atmosphere and very nice staff and manager or owner, told me about his pizza experience in Brooklyn and was very nice! Hostesses and waitstaff great as well!
33 views•1 like
chris.mauro12/20/21, 11:24 p.m.
Perfect crust, phenomenal flavor, fresh tomatoes and delicious mozzarella.
albert.werly2/20/21, 11:13 p.m.
Really good pizza for the area. Great place to take out of town family visiting. Surprised with how much I liked the pizza sauce. Slight charred on the bottom which is great for coal oven. Overall, a great slice
jason.mcleod2/20/21, 6:53 p.m.
Perfectly cooked, according to Pres’ standards. Fresh ingredients for sure. Nothing frozen. Would have preferred more sauce, less cheese, but not a deal breaker. Coal fire is awesome!
cmbentley1/24/21, 2:15 a.m.
Little flop. Oven control was a little off and had some strange spotting patterns. Over all a solid pie and one of the better in the area.
mikey...d1/18/21, 1:51 a.m.
Very good pizza. Quality ingredients. It reminded me a lot of Santucci’s pizza in Philadelphia. Very distinct cheese layer with sauce strictly on top. It was lacking that coal fire taste and crisp. My instinct told me to ask for it well done which I will probably do next time.
juliet.k1/14/21, 2:35 a.m.
Margherita pizza, add pepperoni. One of the best I’ve had in a long time!
dough.nut11/24/20, 12:34 a.m.
Good margarite pizza. Zesty sauce and light airy crust. That's a review.
gblade339/22/20, 1:21 a.m.
Excellent pizza. Nice little crisp, no flop. It’s honestly better then any pizza spot in my home town, Cincinnati. So far my favorite in the Tampa area.
davideacho9/18/20, 4:41 a.m.
Margarita add pepperoni delicious pizza. Good tasting cheese, sauce, and dough
deegee9/14/20, 12:40 p.m.
Cristinos is the best pizza place in the Tampa Bay Area, maybe even all of Florida. Been coming here for years, always satisfied. Great crunch, slight flop. The dough is always very airy, soft, and thin. Cheese is delicious. Sauce is tasty. Love the little pepperonis. This place deserves a higher rating, highly recommend.
joeharris809/11/20, 8:36 p.m.
Fresh, quality ingredients. Crispy crust and good amount of sauce. Don’t like the pepperoni as much as their margarita pizza.