About Cristino's Coal Oven Pizza
1,011 Yelp Reviews
steve.khentigan7/20/22, 10:56 p.m.
We are here visiting from out of town. We went twice. Got straight cheese both times. The first day I would give it a 7.8. Strong pizza but not enough cheese. On the second visit added extra cheese moving the score up to 8.6. Highly recommend this place. As an FYI my wife had the gluten free and she said maybe 6.4. The gelato is in the 9’s as an FYI.
52wkhi7/18/22, 6:19 p.m.
Hands down best pizza in pinellas. Everything is top notch. No flop, no grease and a beautiful under carriage. Staff is incredible as well, called ahead for a pick up as I was leaving my house and as soon as I walked in the door 5mins later there she was in all of her glory
mike.proco7/15/22, 7:03 p.m.
Pizza came out crisp as we asked. Had a nice taste with almost no flop. We enjoyed it. The wing are killer!
barstool-craig7/6/22, 11:13 p.m.
Fresh Italian pizza (Americanized to my liking). The vibes are top tier inside. The pizza is delicious but just lacks a flavorful crust and keeps it out of the high 8’s or 9’s scores. Definitely worth trying in Clearwater Beach.
thelatchdaddy5/9/22, 5:00 p.m.
🚨THIS IS NOT A ROOKIE SCORE🚨 The pizza looks like a mid-8 and the char, sauce and toppings are elite. Now the reason this isn’t higher is because of the flop. It’s a little thicker than it should be, so that keeps it from being higher. Very good price too. Awesome neighborhood spot.
jjbenc4/15/22, 5:09 p.m.
had trouble scoring because the pie was all over the place. some places were a 7.9 others a 6.5. I spit out 7.2 because I panicked. 10/10 would recommend if you’re wanting a cutesie date. this isn’t a date score tho so i’ll go with the reluctant 7.2.
4 views•3 likes
thickbooger4/4/22, 1:48 a.m.
Easily some of the best pizza in the Tampa Bay Area. Fast. Amazing Pizza. Will be coming back.
kyle.yocum2/13/22, 5:09 p.m.
Best Pizza in all of Florida! Under carriage is top notch, coal fired makes it crisp and the sauce is out of this world!
davidf722/12/22, 1:00 a.m.
Thin, crispy crust with great undercarriage. Sauce is solid and pepperoni is the real not the cheap stuff.
nicholas.bright1/30/22, 11:56 p.m.
Great pizza. Crust had nice crisp and was excellently seasoned. Sauce was a little thick and heavy but worked well.
andrew.kornberg10/27/21, 4:01 p.m.
Excellent crunch with a sweet tomato sauce. When in Florida eating this you feel like you’re eating pizza from the northeast. Excellent pie!
tom.garofalo7/22/21, 11:54 p.m.
On vacation from Philly and got this pizza as a recommendation from the chef at the Brown Boxer. Pizza has flavorful sauce and crust was perfectly coal fired crisp.
eman.huling6/18/21, 11:46 p.m.
Some of the best pizza we’ve had in Clearwater. Got the 4 cheese, half with pepperoni.
stevenboe2275/30/21, 12:19 a.m.
Fresh as fuck, dope as fuck, crisp, good burn bubbles, great service!!
floridascott5/24/21, 6:32 p.m.
Clearwater area pizza review. This place has many good reviews, with 59 people and an average rating of 7.9. Two different people recommended this place to me at work. 1. This is a Margherita style pizza with the fresh basil. My first review of one this style. 2. Personally not a fan of having one bite with lots of cheese and then 1 bite of all sauce, better when it's all uniform. 3. On the reviews they were raving about it's delicious ingredients, but I did not think of it much more than pretty good. The coal fired dough was top of the line and made to perfection. 4. From watching Dave from barstool pizza reviews, he most likely would say it is the type of pizza that you would order in fine dining with a glass of wine. 5. My rating is 7.1