Crosby Pizza Stop

Solid but Louie and Ernie’s and Tommy’s is better in this area

I’ve hyped this place up for a few years and finally today can say it lives up with the round Sicilian. This is how you make a killer Sicilian, great crunch on the bottom, pillowy middle that compresses upon each bite with a tangy sauce and gooey blanket of cheese on top. Awesome overall flavor, great old school spot and one of the best slices I’ve had in the Bronx. Signature slice that you gotta try!!!

Best Sicilian slice on the planet

Solid NYC pizza especially by the slice, regular slice is great… they also have thicker slices that also do the job and are just as good

Visited family today and had to stop by my favorite slice shop when I was a kid. Still a massive slice with no flop and excellent crisp. The ratios were slightly in favor of the cheese but it was a good quality low moisture. Sauce was one but was overshadowed by the grease. Remember it being better when I was younger but still a solid neighborhood joint.

My favorite pizza growing up as a kid. I must say the regular slice is good but the Sicilian is where it’s at. That round Sicilian pie they are famous for is a well-deserved reputation. As far as the regular, it’s your typical New York slice. It’s got a decent mixture of crunch and chew, and the sauce is above average. The Sicilian is easily over a 9. I’d say a 9.3 on the Sicilian and a 7.8 on the plain.

The regular had a weird flavor. Kind of tastes like out of state pizza trying their hardest to tastes like NY pizza. The Sicilian was good but nowhere near the best. Score is for the regular slice

Nice big slices. Good crunch. Good taste. Zero flop. Thin! Tad greasy. But overall good.

The pizza is so good I forgot to take a picture definitely worth the try get the Sicilian round slice

Very good slice. Cheese to sauce is very good. The crust is thin but has very good crunch. Definitely a slice I would travel for if in the area.

On the grill. Not my style. Too much dough not crispy

THIS is a New York slice. When they coined the phrase “New York Slice,” they must’ve had Crosby Pizza in mind. Cheese is great. Crust is great. Virtually no flop. Great crispness all around. Sauce is a little sweet, but the cheese and the pie itself more than make up for it.

Solid slice.