Cusumano

Not the most famous name in the Old Forge pizza game, but probably the best example of the style done well.

Another great Old Forge tray! Light fluffy crust with a crispy undercarriage. Fantastic!

No flop, great crisp, great overall slice for sure. If you’re looking for old forge pizza, this might be as good as it gets. Will definitely never say no to popping in here for pizza and a few drinks.

Cheese bread

This place was the worst pizza we’ve ever had we were here January 8th 2021 and we were served by a musty backwards hat cigarette smoking bum that charged us 10 dollars even for the worst pizza I’ve ever eaten. It tasted like dog shit worst pizza I’ve ever had for being the “pizza capital of the world” (Acuro and genel was a solid 7.4 with good service)

The dough was pillow like and crisp almost buttery . The sauce to cheese ratio was very good , and that cheese blend really makes the old forge pizza experience. The better of the 2 I had.

Pinkies out at this place...but the pizza is good!

Alright, if the Prez thinks this is the best in Old Forge, who am I to argue. I have always liked Salerno’s and Revello’s with Pepperoni, however this is better. Great sauce, great cheese, and the crust...very light, very airy. My score reflects my love of Old Forge pizza and this being the best of it.