Fantastic sauce. 0 crunch. Fantastic thickness. Overall great slice
d-pizza10/3/21, 5:04 p.m.
Decent. Tasty crust and char, but a little thick and no real crisp. Sauce and cheese are good. It’s a cool place, but very expensive. This pie and a margarita pie were nearly $60. Not looking to repeat in light of the competition in the neighborhood, which is superior in every way.
mitch.gurevich9/25/21, 7:24 p.m.
In today’s matchup of classic vs fancy the clear winner was old school. Not at all a given with me. This pie was very light and flavorful especially the sauce and the stracciatella. The sour dough was not the same taste like Driftwood Oven in Pittsburgh. It was sort of a miss for me. Too “bready”. Maybe unfair that I had this right after Sally’s.
pizzaqueen079/1/21, 7:50 p.m.
Why are people not talking about this place??? Everything about this margarita pie is perfection. Out of all the new haven places I’ve tried this is definitely up there with being one of the best places.
ryan.rutherford8/23/21, 6:51 p.m.
New Haven is filled with old world coal-fired pizzerias that have been around since the 1930s, but this is a modern establishment using wood-fired ovens instead. They advertise “artisanal pizzas” here, which is a fancy way of saying “handmade, without machinery.” The specialty pizzas look amazing, really great toppings and interesting combinations; but I reviewed the gold medal pie here, a regular cheese pizza. You’ll notice some big time char, borderline burnt crust, which is a trademark of wood-fired pies. However, the dough is actually softer and less crispy than the New Haven coal-fired pizzas, which must have something to do with how hot the oven gets with wood as opposed to coal. Very nice melt and consistency with the cheese, terrific creaminess & flavor. But the ingredients that bolsters the score the most is the super spunky sauce. Zip, zest, tang & bang, the sauce is the standout star of the pie. In fact, if Pepe’s, Modern or Zuppardi’s had this sauce, all of those pizzas would rate in the 9s. While the non-crispy charred dough drags the rating down a bit, the sauce makes this place worth a try. It’s a great date spot with a new school vibe and very solid pizza. I might have to try a specialty pie the next time I’m here.
art.kelly8/7/21, 7:21 p.m.
Barbecue di Maiale pizza is insane. One of the best slices I’ve ever had. Defiantly a must have.
danny.miller118/1/21, 12:39 a.m.
This place gets an 8.5 for the honeypot slice. Spicy with sopressata, really tasty. The regular half is like a 7.2.
stephanie.mp7/21/21, 10:27 p.m.
Dalegnas margherita - my all time favorite pizza. Just perfect
jeremy.chandler16/27/21, 7:49 p.m.
Light, tender crust - generous cheese - a bit saucy - great New Haven pie
joseph.gattilia1/12/20, 5:49 p.m.
Great pizza. Definitely has some flop. A bit greasy but the sauce has great flavor. My Fiancé tried the vegan pizza she gave it a 10 (rookie score)
joey.scott111/16/19, 9:13 p.m.
Right amount of char, more tang then i really like. A little more cheese would be great.
headshoes11/3/19, 11:47 p.m.
They had 2 ovens going with pies getting cooked in under 3 min (I timed them) To compare, this was your better then average Neo spot here in NJ. Sauce was very good, crust was nice. However seeing other orders, if you add any toppings here, you will have yourself a mess.
buske9/27/19, 3:46 a.m.
Fresh, solid slice with a very nice sauce and char. Had a vegan option as well that was easily the best vegan pie I’ve ever had. Very legit.