Dayton Street Apizza

Leaving a second review here because lately the pizza has been inconsistent, sometimes on the undercooked side. I think they have been cycling through chefs.

A serious hidden gem because it’s located on the outskirts of New Haven, but do not sleep on Dayton Street. It’s tasty without being gourmet, and it will be served on either the largest tray or pizza box you will ever encounter. Their pepperoni is thin and fresh, and the crust cooked to perfection. If you’re there, support local, and get a Foxon Park cream soda. Your taste buds will be eternally grateful to this impeccable review.

Cheese fell apart when I pulled the slices apart. Solid undercarriage with light char. Good pie, tasted even better because I was so freaking hungry

Undercooked, not bad. If not In New Haven, would be an amazing pie.

My gf and I were blown away. First time having apizza, definitely recommend this place

Solid pie, would recommend.

Nice crisp, decent crust flavor, average sauce flavor, average cheese. I had to add quite a bit red peppers. I’ve had better, I’ve had worse.

Mehhhhh 🤷🏼‍♂️

Kinda burnt, pretty meh

Solid pizza, nothing close to new havens best #PauliePizzaReview