After looking at the reviews on one bite app (high 8 and 9s) I had to check this pizza place out... that and it was very close to my customer. Grossly high on the scores. I did like the sauce, I liked the brick oven cook, crust had a nice crunch. I could taste the mozzarella cheese. The bad... the pizza was a bit soupy, major Raritan flop. The crust was too dry, lacked flavor, was on a flat note (not enough yeast used or dead yeast)?
Order now on Slice
Order DeLucia's Brick Oven Pizza
Hungry? Order right now on Slice
scott.seidman1/15/23, 7:11 a.m.
Three times your out. We have gone three times. You would think if you had a restaurant you would want butt in seats. The restaurant was empty. I have been in the food business for 30+ years. We were told we can sit there for 2 1/2 hr and we can have a pizza. They don’t seam interested in the restaurant business. Just take out.
andrew.brooks12/31/22, 2:11 a.m.
Great crisp, great cheese, I'd like slightly more tang. Worth every bite though!
sam.l..12/30/22, 11:24 p.m.
Lives up to the hype, can’t see it in the 9’s but fantastic pizza.
mead.briggs12/28/22, 9:38 p.m.
One of the best pizzas I’ve ever had . No flop . Crispy. Amazing cheese to sauce ratio . Highly recommend
saltinmyeye12/28/22, 3:29 a.m.
Big disappointment. Poor crisp, kind of spongy. Flavour is very average. Felt like it was in the box a while despite picking up on time. Slightly cool, definitely wasn’t hot and fresh. Davey what’s going on?
iamnota_hipstr12/17/22, 11:46 p.m.
Good quality, crispy and light. Sauce had goo flavor. Definitely a pizza you want to eat right out of the oven.
jennifer.pruneau12/16/22, 5:44 p.m.
Buffalo chicken pizza and the plain pies were both amazing!!! Will totally pick up another pie or 3 when I’m in the area 😊
levinemachine11/15/22, 7:04 p.m.
First impression is that the slices are as straight as a hockey stick with no flex. The hard crust has zero “flop”, So we know why Barstool’s Presidente gave it a 9.4. You would think that the undercarriage would have more crunch for the lack of flop. It has a very inconsistent thickness. There’s an abundance of tasty cheese on top of a delicious savory sauce.
tony.apples11/13/22, 6:36 a.m.
Good pie, tough to call 9.4. Time capsule joint worth something. Has its unique qualities. The dough is good, gets a cracker/bread type crisp, flourish. Cheese is on salty side not much “milk” richness. Sauce not a player. Also got pepperoni which was solid. 3-4 hrs if you collect pizza boxes. 30min if not.
adammjensen11/9/22, 2:08 a.m.
First thing you notice about the pizza is the look of a 9+ pie. The second, is the lack of flop. It was concave on the bottom, slanting upward. Never seen anything like it. Didn’t get a ton of flavor in sauce or cheese, crust was average. I shadow portnoy because we have similar preference in pie but once again I think he’s WAY off
kyle.knepper11/3/22, 9:46 p.m.
Amazing crisp, perfect undercarriage, and it retained its crisp in the box for 30 minutes back to the hotel. Great pizza!
gimmesomepie10/31/22, 12:59 a.m.
A little disappointing. Very crispy, but sort of tough like a frozen pizza. Also tasted salty, lacking the flavor I hoped for.
craig.lahey10/29/22, 1:00 a.m.
Went here based on Dave’s review and it didn’t disappoint! Another one on the thin side and great flavor. No flop.
s.rind10/25/22, 10:07 p.m.
Firm, flavorful, well done without needed to be ordered that way specifically. These lowball scorers are out of their mind…. This is 9.3 all day long
whatispizza510/20/22, 8:42 p.m.
If there was a pizza purgatory where all you do is eat pizza this is the pie I would choose. I was prepared to say “overrated” based on the hype. I simply can’t. It has the best qualities of a bar pie but the crust is strong and sturdy so doesn’t fit in that category. Unlike traditional bar pies that break into pieces this holds strong with an impactful crunch. You also can’t write off the sauce. It makes you gitty like when I first saw the movie milk money in grade school. This is like a cover band playing the best of federici, santillo and Nancy’s all in one night. Superb!
theresa.striffler10/20/22, 4:45 p.m.
Good. A little bland for my liking. Very crispy, too crispy for my preference. Solid pizza. Wouldn’t make another special trip.
oppadaddy00710/20/22, 12:16 a.m.
My expectations for DeLucia’s were very high, but they somehow managed to exceed them. The cheese and sauce are well balanced. The crust is baked to absolute perfection - light, airy, and crispy. They sell out very quickly so make sure to call ahead early! I highly recommend this place.
pizzajeans10/17/22, 3:53 p.m.
I was expecting a lot more given the hype. The cheese isn’t as fresh as you’d expect and the sauce is adequate. The real dealbreaker is the undercarriage. It tastes much like a pie crust you would find in an actual pie (i.e. key lime or pecan) which is thick and strong. The crust edges are pretty good but a little burnt. I can understand why some would like this style of pizza, but I just didnt click with it, especially given how hyped I was.