Di Fara Pizza

Waited 42 minutes for a slice and it wasn't even what I ordered. Crust is inedible. Identical to chewing on cardboard.

Lives up to the hype, Worth the wait and drive from Queens. Crispy and sauce very flavorful. Also really enjoyed the square.

Eaten on 9/923

Worth the trek deep into Brooklyn. Lived up to the hype.

Not worth the 9.4 Dave gave it. It was greasy (ruined my shirt with dripping grease) and it was so chewy it hurt my jaw to eat two pieces.

Crispy crust, plenty of flavor

Very hot and crisp. Super tasty sauce

Their square slice is what I’m rating here. Such a unique flavor to their pizza

Made me weak in the knees. Perfect oiliness, perfectly fresh Basil, amazing saltiness of the cheese, slight flop yet foldable. Audible MMMs escaped my mouth the entire time. Also had the square, and oh man. Maybe even better than a the classic. Light and airy, impeccably sweet/fresh sauce. I’ll be back again and again.

Drove an hour and twenty minutes for this... not quite worth that far, especially if you live somewhere that has good pizza more nearby, but this is very good pizza. Even tho it's thin, it feels substantial. Without pepperoni is crisper and better than with it.

Solid slice was expecting more though. Still above average

Totally lived up to the hype. Best cheese pizza I’ve ever eaten. And the people were great. And we barely had to wait since we called ahead.

Lives up to the hype! I wish there was a tiny bit of sweetness added to the sauce as this would push it into the mid 9s.

When Dom started cutting up the basil you knew it was go time! I know it’s just bread, sauce and cheese, but the way Dom made pizza elevated it to something magical. Simply the best pizza I’ve ever had. (Photo cred to Di Fara’s)

Super solid, nice crunch, fresh bail is great!

First time here, so I got both the regular and square. It’s really good pizza, but not hitting the 9’s for me. The sauce is one of the best I’ve had, cheese is top notch, and the flavor is there, but the crust is where it loses it a little for me. It’s definitely a heavier and thicker crust than I would have thought, but I’d still recommend making a trip out and trying it for yourself.

Am I at the right Di Fara? This was dry and not impressive. The oil and basil gave it taste reminiscent of Grandma slices I’ve had before. It wasn’t bad pizza, but it’s not easy to get here and the bar was set all the way up. I was hoping to experience the best pizza I ever had. This slices lands in the high 6’s. Maybe if I ordered a whole pie? I’m sad about this one

This is what life is about. Nothing fancy here except for the extreme pizza craftsmanship. My pizza buddy called it the best pizza in the nation. Who could argue? Serious bucket list experience. Well done, chewy, crunchy, flavor — it’s got it all.

Worth the drive from Pennsylvania. A pizza religious experience!