Best square in Brooklyn!!!
pmw2/28/21, 6:18 a.m.
Outstanding pizza. One of the most flavorful slices I’ve ever had. I need to try again as I picked it up about 15 min after it came out of oven but regardless a 9.0. Start with crust-perfect, thin but crispy with perfect flop. Sauce - nice flavor. Not overbearing, but I would like a little more quantity and if I’m being ultra picky maybe a touch sweeter. Basil and park throughout the slice created this awesome almost spice (which I picked up might have been garlic too?) grease and oil and cheese selection is unreal here. All in all an incredible slice that is rated high for a reason.
nick.bada.bing2/26/21, 11:39 a.m.
No way Dave! I grew up on Sally’s New Haven, CT lived in Brooklyn, had Di Fara’s, NO WAY its better than Sally’s! NO FREAKING WAY! Di Fara yes awesome pizza, Domenico De Marco, the last of the MASTER PIZZA MAKERS, God Bless him!!! but Sally’s has a coal oven. Unfortunately Di Fara does not. Sally’s Apizza!
kostas.panagiotakis2/25/21, 11:58 p.m.
Speechless! Do not waste your time here! Dough was terrible, flavor almost nonexistent!
stephen.ciccone1/30/21, 7:44 p.m.
Best grandmas slice I’ve ever had. Regular slice was great too but a little messy and greasy. Still great pizza
ecao1/29/21, 5:24 a.m.
Cheese pie: seemingly nice ingredients; a very pleasant smell, distinct to Di Fara, consequently has to very good flavor as well but unfortunately that’s where the positives end as I simply can’t seem to get a hot pizza from here whether it was just taken out of the oven or sitting for a while; nice crunchiness, but falls apart in your hand, you can’t even fold in half, seems like a new oven would help (I know they got a really old one) heat is clearly not distributed right; basil seemed old, cheese tastes good, but seems off, perhaps because it wasn’t hot; sauce is good Square slice: sauce isn’t overwhelming, but the sourness kind of takes over; crust has a nice flavor, good crunch, doesn’t fall apart like the regular pie which is good; just one small circle of mozzarella, not nearly enough as I didn’t really get a taste of it (7.6/10)
goul.jones1/10/21, 12:47 a.m.
Greasy,wet boom, that's a review, pizza piiza...had to wait 2 hour for 2 slice,,,,and dice
janis1/7/21, 9:46 p.m.
Cheese slice was special the crust was tasty with a special seasoning. The cheese and sauce had so much flavor. 9.3 Grandma corner slice. Think was the last one was a bit cold hard to judge it but was surprisingly the disappointment of the two. 8.2
thephillyscumbag1/5/21, 3:01 a.m.
Rookie Score? FOH! Couldn’t give it a better score for Maggie’s sake 🥺 but she’s so nice. Honestly risked the Rones for the Fara. Didn’t have a sanitizer after travelling on the Subway during its peak in the city but hey the pizza gods saved my ass. My only pet peeve is the olive oil on top just makes it a wee bit greasy. Lucali by the slimmest of margins.
ryan.onebite.clifford12/30/20, 12:58 a.m.
Certainly came here for the hype and was not disappointed to say the least. Triangle slice was much better, but that’s because we got ours fresh. Similar to what everyone else is saying the ingredients were fresh. Straight off the boat from Italy. The not over cooked part of the square slice was great as well, but the ingredients slid off the slice for some. My highest review so far, and if it wasn’t such a pain to get here, I could eat this everyday!
75 views•1 like
frank.bianco12/27/20, 3:40 p.m.
I drove all the way from Philadelphia with high hopes based off the reviews and was extremely disappointed. We waited 2 hours from when the order was placed for this cold mess they sold me. After driving for 2 hours then waiting 2 hours what was I to do but take it Nor worth the trip I can get better Pizza in Philly.