The square slice is hands down superior than the regular
ryan.campbell125/29/20, 2:16 a.m.
Lives up to the hype. Can tell the ingredients are super fresh. Love the basil on top. If I’m going to be picky maybe a touch too much crust, but this is one of the best pies in the city.
pizza_joe5/23/20, 12:41 p.m.
Fire pizza and worth the drive from NJ. Lit all of my taste buds on fire when I bit into the pizza. Way better than Lucali too. Will def be back sauce so so good Would give the round a 9.4 if no flop at the bottom of the slice. But straight fire pizza 🔥
steven.flaherty15/17/20, 10:03 p.m.
Drove from CT to try this pizza that Dave rated a 9.4 Gotta admit, it was amazing.
kirsch5/8/20, 11:22 p.m.
Quarantine finally gave me the opportunity to try the legendary DiFara! Crust was a 9.7, rest good, but a little too greasy to crack a 9.
alk616955/8/20, 7:51 p.m.
Had it brought home due to everything going on right now so I'm sure if I ate it fresh, it would be in the 9's. Never the less, still a great slice. Had the square.
noel.damico5/6/20, 5:50 p.m.
Pizza was way over hyped!!!!!!! Ordinary slice very disappointed won’t be coming back!!!
glenn.carroll4/27/20, 12:11 a.m.
This was not worth the drive, nor risking my life with Covid. The place was also a shit show, I understand why they have a pie called “chaos.” Can’t hold a candle to Johns of Bleeker, anything in New Haven, or Brooklyn Square in Jackson. I tried to get Lucali but the pick up time was too late. I should have just waited. Only worth it if you find yourself, for some ungodly reason, in that part of Brooklyn.
anish.gala4/24/20, 1:52 p.m.
Excellent pie best to eat it fresh! Mushrooms aren’t worth it. Stick with the classics
rxvette4/13/20, 4:52 p.m.
Ordered some from Goldbelly. Really great fresh taste and a sauce that was amazing. Would recommend if it’s in your budget or for a date night.
trump-of-pizza3/29/20, 6:17 p.m.
Second time reviewing this pie, and it’s better! Pizza doesn’t get better than this, it’s pretty much the perfect pie. Light, Crispy, Flavorful..Best Pizza possibly ever! 9.2!
sgt.pizza3/27/20, 6:49 p.m.
Regular everyone knows how good it is 9.1 Sicilan: 9.6 best sicilan I've ever had
alec.brady3/24/20, 9:24 p.m.
Best pizza in the world! Use to be a 10 when don was there but still nothing can compare, recommend the square
pizzaqueen073/18/20, 1:50 a.m.
Wouldn’t say it’s the best pizza in the world but definitely good. Just a bit over hyped in my opinion.
alex.monterville3/16/20, 8:32 p.m.
Confused. I’m not a picky guy when it comes to pizza. This pizza looked fantastic, and coupled with the rave reviews I was expecting way more flavor. Maybe just got a bad pie 🤷♂️ it was pretty boring.