Di Fara Pizza

Ok, went waaay outside of the city to the middle of Brooklyn to try this famous pizza place and it didn’t disappoint! It definitely was not the best pizza I’ve ever had, but it was still very good. There was no flop, and the ingredients were very fresh. I thought the crust could’ve used a little more flavor, but I did enjoy the cheese and the sauce. My only other complaint was the amount of basil on the pie, I’m not wild about basil and theirs was a little too overpowering.

Had it cold and this was still a 9.4! Great balance on the dough and sauce ratio with a perfect crunch! Same rating as John’s Pizza on Bleeker!! Congrats to both! 👏👏

🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥UNREAL

Visiting NYC from Florida and decided to make the commute to Brooklyn to try the legendary Di Fara’s. Tried the circle and the square pizza. Both were really good slices and I enjoyed them thoroughly. If I’m ever in Brooklyn I will stop by again but I wouldn’t make more than an hour commute for it. A little too strong on the basil for my liking but the crust, cheese, and sauce were all quality ingredients and it showed in the flavor. I actually preferred the square over the circle pizza.

This place was very good. I think the 9.4 from Dave is high on the regular slice but the square slice is the best I have ever had!!! It’s amazing and made my trip to NY worth it!! This is a blended score. 9.1 on regular slice 9.5 on square.

One nibble. Everyone knows the laws. That this is the best slice you’ll ever have. It don’t get any better than this. Dom (the son) was so humble and friendly it shows how much love was put into this. You can literally taste it. 9.3 for the cheese slice. 9.4 for the cheese square. That square is gonna be remembered for years!

Gave this another shot. It’s meh. Ok. Overrated. Sauce is runny and bland. Crust was good. I’ll take A New Haven pizza over this anytime.

This was literally the most basic pizza I ever tasted. Nothing stood out. It was nothing more than average and super expensive for absolutely no reason. It was good but nothing spectacular as y’all made it out to be. I’ve had really great pizza, and this was not even close to great. Sorry not sorry. Save your money and go somewhere else.

2nd best pizza ever had! Still doesn’t top Johns of Bleecker!

Tremendous. The fresh mozzarella is great. The fresh basil is a fantastic addition. The crust is like a cracker. Whatever olive oil they use is outstanding. Do yourself a favor and go to Di Fara.

Really fucking good. Worth the drive!!!

Very well put together slice but a weeee bit salty, agree with the community score

Best Pizza I’ve had in New York. I had one warm and one cold and despite not being a 9.5 cold, it’s undoubtedly still an 8+. This is a pizza you take an hour long subway ride for. Delicious, and the best I’ve had in NY so far.

Best pizza in New York, maybe the best in the country. This deserves a perfect 10 but I’m leaving room for the possibility that there could be 1 or 2 better pizzas in the world.

electric crunch fantastic

Not what it used to be. I’m talking 20 years ago. Had some slices yesterday. Crust seemed slightly stale, off tastes of a dirty oven. It’s certainly not bad pizza, just isn’t very good, by the slice at least. Maybe better with a whole pie.

Definitely amazing pizza. Not sure if it’s dropped slightly in quality since Dom retired because 9.4 seems a little high Dave. I’ll score 9.1 because I think it belongs on the bottom of the top 10 instead of the top. Legendary pizza but not the king.

Pizza was good. Definitely a bit overrated. A tad too much basil for my liking. Overall pretty good. Nothing special

Its a great pizza but the hype and the price, i didn’t feel it was worth it. Definitely the best so far of the previous reviews. But i have had better pizza and i will definitely find better pizza. For the drive and price in a effect 7.9 !!

As advertised NY style pizza (and square slice). Burnt bottom to perfection and balanced cheese/sauce.