Di Maggio's Pizzeria

Has good crunch, little flop, sauce is a little too sweet.

Had it fresh right after opening while I was a camp counselor. While fresh pizza is easily high 7s.

Sesame crust is great but it’s a very heavy/thick slice. Very cheesy, almost too much. Not a lot of sauce until you get to the end at the crust. Good drunk slice.

Apparently Billy Joel came to this place as a kid. Good neighborhood slice.

I ordered from this restaurant because people are around town are raving it and giving it a good thumbs up so I wanted to give it a try for myself. I’m very disappointed the sauce is so bland and it doesn’t even taste like there’s any mozzarella on it. Absolutely no flavor I had to put Italian seasoning and pizza seasoning on top of it just to make it edible. The only good thing about it is the sesame crust. But very disappointed and I won’t be ordering from them again. I had high hopes for this. The only reason I gave it a 5.6 is because of the crust. If it didn’t have a sesame crust it would’ve been in the 4’s.

Me and my girl were driving by and I noticed the name of the place and said “ay oh, I’d try that place for the name alone.” When she told me she used to go there with her friends after school and it’s been around since the 80s, I banged a U-Turn and we headed in. The place looks like it’s from the 80s, I dig it. As far as the pizza goes, good taste, liked the sesame crust… just a touch too much cheese maybe, and definitely too greasy. But the overall taste was good. Also reminded me of the 80s… ay oh.

best grandma hands down, their regular pie is a joke but you have to get what is good there, amazing grandma slice

I know their pizza can be better… I’ve had it better but I came today with the sole purpose of rating it and they gave me this disgusting thrown up looking slice. How unappetizing. Just a greasy gross mess. Will not come back here.

No flop. Garlic knots are in sane.

Regular and s grandma. Both have sesame see crust. Nice crisp on both. Regular could use more sauce. Sauce a little bland

Very good

2nd pie 2nd review same score

Solid. Thin crust, sesume crust

Thin slice. Sauce could use some work. Average

Def the best za on this part of the island. Sweet sauce, thin crust without the cardboard char taste on the bottom.

Great crust. Little flop. Such a shame of how good of a crust it had and such a weak sauce and cheese. Both sauce and cheese taste cheap. Almost like a frozen taste.

Nothing special, little too greasy

Paper thin crust with good flavor. Cheese is excellent! Not to sweet of sauce, sesame seeds on crust is different but is quite nice as well.

Don’t let this not so nice looking strip mall deter you from a good solid slice. Crust is paper thin and crisp, sauce is sweet and although not a fan of sesame seeds, the sesame seed crust is a nicely balanced so it is not over powering.

Yum!!!

Average Long Island slice little oily nothing special