DiCarlo's Pizza - Downtown Steubenville

Not my style but I thought I would give it a try. The crunch on the crust is awesome and the sauce is pretty good, but I prefer the cheese melted in the oven. I would eat it again for sure.

Locally loved. I get it. Probably nothing else around. But this pizza is just not that good. Not worth any type of travel for. Crust is good. That’s it. Sauce has no flavor. Cheese is flavorless. It’s a different experience with cold toppings. A lot better places that do this in Pittsburgh. But if your from around the area and grew up on this pizza I get why you love and defend it. For me it gets a 4.2

Taste like chef boyardee. Very crispy crust

Very good pizza, sauce is great, crust a little overdone.

great crisp, sauce is fine, but that cheese, baby.👌definitely a step above other similarly styled pizza.

Good crunch, sauce is pretty good. Crust is excellent

In my opinion the best Di Carlo’s. Even though I grew up in Weirton.

Perfect crunch, delicious tomato sauce and perfect amount of cheese. Best pizza in this area hands down.