Dive Bar Pizza

Crispy, good cheese. Nothin special about the sauce. Overall, very solid.

Great pizza when visiting Montauk

The Grandma was epic!!! Cool spot off the beach with a great vibe, Cool staff.. Sauce and cheese was on point.

🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻

Grandma was excellent 9.1 White 7.7 Reg 7.5

Similar to the other locations, in Brooklyn and New Paltz but doesn’t beat the original place. Definitely the best in the montauk area.

Great tomato sauce not amazing crust good cheese best pizza in the Hamptons (it is a dive bar)

Can tell Best Pizza knows what they’re doing. Great sauce taste, good cheese ratio. Despite being a reheat slice, had excellent crisp in every bite.

Unique pie would be better if crispier

Put this place on your bucket list or whatever list you got… cool atmosphere, and pizza is SO good. I clearly scored the regular, but that Grandma with garlic and pepperoni was a 9.4 for me. One of the best slices I’ve ever had… ever.

Perfect crust, great all around slice, it’s a light slice, not in weight but eatability, great ingredients. Excellent work, good staff, fun bar. Thank you.

The basil on the slice was unexpected but appreciated. White Pie slice is easily an 8.8 slice.

Perfect pizza Franklyn. Marinara is phenomenal, undercarriage crispy and crunchy, with fresh cheese. The best of the best Franky. That’s a fucking review!!!

Needs a little more sauce

Best Pizza in Montauk, NY Thin and crispy, good flavor

“Best Pizza” was delicious, similar to the one in Brooklyn. Crispy, sauce was amazing, and thin.

As far as a beach pie goes, this is fantastic. Pizza was super fresh, not a lot of grease, nice oregano and basil. Cheese is very good. Not a lot of flop, nice char, and great crust. Nothing to knock here, great pizza.