Domenico's Pizza

Bottom wasn’t crispy cheese and sauce tasted ok. Not bad for Staten Island pizza lol but not Brooklyn pizza

Straight up better than average NY slice. A little over cheese like they usually are but good taste and well done with great crisp. Good undercarriage with not flop. Nice people as well and cozy little place to eat.

Solid Margherita! Crust is surprisingly light, slightly chewy and melts in your mouth. That sauce was very fresh. Needed more char and some grated cheese. Not the airiest crust but good crunch.

Sauce had a nice flavor. Very good pizza.

very football pizza. the sauce/cheese combo is tasty. each ingredient compliments each other. however the crust is a different story. it’s almost rubbery. there’s a tug when you bite into the crust which isn’t my thing. it should either be soft or a burnt bottom, it shouldn’t be a little bit of both.

Good balance of sauce and cheese, good sauce, cooked well, and not too heavy. It’s been my local go-to lately. They’ve got great panini as well

Good pie...may have been a little to crunchy, but overall a good pizza. My palate was a little scraped from the crunchiness. Cheese was excellent with a perfect amount of grease. I was hopeful for a little more tang in the sauce. Again, it was a good pizza.

Solid cheese slice. Not too greasy or oily. Good football pie as el presidente says. Vodka slice was good as well.

Standard run of the mill pizza, pretty greasy but still enjoyable.

Solid slice. Crisp and firm. A bit too greasy on top for me though.