Domenic's & Vinnie's Pizza

Best square pizza around Crunchy Great undercarriage No flop jalop Best guys around!

Domenic’s and Vinnie’s in Middlebury serves hands-down the best pizza I’ve ever had—every bite feels like home, with crust and sauce that hit on a whole different level. This place is the real deal… someone should tell Portnoy to see for himself.

Well done, crispy. No flop. Sweet sauce. This place always does it right. A++++.

Great cheese pizza! Been going for years and it’s one of the better pies amongst some other great places!

Good crisp. Much thinner than they usually make them, which isn’t necessarily a bad thing. Sweet sauce, zero flop. Pretty decent experience. Past visits I’d have given it 7.7-7.8, but it’s always a safe bet either way.

Might be best in CT

Great tasting, great looking ! Could’ve been left in a little bit longer for the undercarriage

We have been here plenty of times, Dave would love the cheese! We got half buffalo chicken and falf broccoli with green pepper

Some of the best pizza you’ll ever have. Thin and crispy crust! This is the baked potato pizza, but the margarita and cheese are just as good!

One bite everybody know the rules. Great undercarriage. Great sauce. My favorite. Better than New Haven imo

People love this pizza. Sauce way too sweet. Two hour wait for phone in on a Friday night, Probably because of the lack of good pizza in Woodbury Middlebury Southbury. I believe it’s overrated.

Delicious!

Good but seriously overrated. The sauce is a bit thick and acidic, the crust is often on the burnt side, and the crust can be chewy. It’s decent pizza but not an 8.0+. No way. Another huge drawback is that they only take cash or check and are incredibly overpriced. A large cheese pizza with one topping is over $22-23.00. That’s ridiculous. In this day a restaurant should accept credit cards. Again, good but far from great.

Crispy, great sauce. No flop or crazy grease. Simply the bomb

I hated this floppy mess, sauce was very acidic and burns the roof of your mouth. Nothing good about it, doesn’t even come in a box. It gets a 3 because it’s pizza. Ate 2 pieces and tossed the rest, not even worthy of a re heat.

One of the best in the area.

Perfect crispy / chewy crust balance. Flavorful crust. Seasoned well throughout. Very impressed as a first time orderer.

Dom and Vinnies is my favorite pizza place in CT besides the mother of all pizza places: Pepe’s. Their pepperoni and bacon pizza is my favorite. They get it right. The crust, the sauce, the toppings. It’s just a work of art. There’s something they do to the bacon and pepperoni that makes it fat less. I swear to god. The pizzas are square and as a guy who isn’t a fan of crust, the middle pieces are my favorite. Pure good stuff. Best pizza around. Can’t fucking beat it!

Thin and crispy, classic sauce with some tang to it. If you do toppings, sausage and pepper is great. The Waterbury location I prefer, but Middlebury is 2 minutes away. Domenic and Vinnie’s, cheese pizza coming in high with 8.9. That’s a review.

Damn good pizza ... thin crust, square slices