About Don Carmelo’s Pizzeria
40 Yelp Reviews
jt.olsen6/13/21, 12:09 a.m.
Sauce and cheese are great. Crust is great. There is some flop but also crispy. Best I’ve had in Omaha area
royal.redskin5/28/20, 5:36 a.m.
My personal favorite pizza in Omaha. The sauce has a unique kick to it and its the best NY pizza you can get here in Omaha
adimasi9545/9/20, 12:58 a.m.
As someone from the 6th burrough of New York(South Florida) I have a pretty good understanding of NY style pizza. Don Carmelo's is the closet to that in Nebraska. Good flavor, good bang for buck. A little soupy in the middle but overall decent pie! P.s. Fuck Jacks(Frozen pizza company) No disrespect!
ad1cted3/12/19, 6:03 p.m.
Honestly, this is my go to pizza place. Take that as you will but I always have loved Donny C’s. That being said I wanted to keep this a fair review and treat it as if I hadn’t been here before. New York style pizza with thin crust, and a solid flop. Sauce is sweeter which I enjoy and the cheese has a ton of flavor but was kinda greasy. Overall this is the place I usually take people when they come in from out of town and want pizza and it has never disappointed. 7.7
kegan.hruza3/12/19, 5:57 p.m.
Rating on cheese only. Solid pizza. Not overly memorable, but good. Good crust, slightly zesty sauce. Really greasy pizza, but good.