Don Pepi Pizza

Excellent crust on flavorless pie. Find in a pinch.

Good crunch and cheese. Does the job.

Just an average NY slice. Fine if you are swinging through penn station

TBH exceeded my expectations. Have had worse. Better theb the other place in penn station

Average pizza

Minus the smell of the station, this is a pretty great slice!

I’ve always thought Don Pepi Pizza made a good slice.

Very crispy crust and fantastic flavor from the cheese. One of the best pizza places in NY, very weird review from Dave for this one, no idea what he was eating. I thought it was amazing

Good slice..Crispy! Needs more sauce

It was a bit pricey for a standard slice (almost $4), but it does have solid flavor.

Drunk and this was still whack.

Sauce is bland and thin. No real crispness in the dough or the crust for that matter either. Cheese is not that good. This pie reminds he of a Pizza Hut breadstick dipped in Hunts sauce and that’s not a good thing. For $3.50 a slice its a ripoff. There is better pizza around Penn Station for sure.

Crisp crust but kinda flavorless

Brutally boring pizza, tucker carlson knows as much about pizza as he does about economic policy if this is his favorite, sauce was a complete nothing, cheese and crust sucked as well. I thought for sure the roni slice would save it, but WRONG AGAIN you bowtie wearing bastard! What a sad slice

For subway pizza, Don Pepsi’s is a solid slice, good football style pizza

Solid Slices here... not overly greasy either...

Cheese and sauce were ok. I liked the crust. Typical slice