About Donatina Neapolitan Pizza Cafe
125 Yelp Reviews
steve.hudsons10/16/20, 11:13 a.m.
Clam pie 8.1 Wood fire pesto marnina and burrata 8.4 Detroit slice it was very salty . I dont think detroit is a good counter serve reheat slice 6.2 The grandma was average 7.1 Didnt even bother with regular , it looked terrible
wurmlife10/10/20, 4:50 p.m.
Cheese had a strong parmigiana taste to it, nice and crispy crust, sauce was alright. overall a good slice
t-rex.pizza5/31/20, 9:53 p.m.
Too doughy and chewy. Kinda upset because the flavor was great. If this was thin and crispy, if would be a an 8+ easy.
juan.rivera25/23/20, 6:54 p.m.
Stale as hell. Dried to shit, barely any sauce, Suffolk County dangle dick... chewy AF very bad pizza. Their bbq pulled pork, Detroit style is much better but the sauce is a little watery and sugary...6.8
wadezzeria1/20/20, 12:17 a.m.
Tried 3 slices: regular cheese, detroit and grandma... cheese slice was decent... good sauce/cheese ratio but the bottom crust was a bit thin... i was given the last slice of the old pie as i stared at the fresher pie on display... the detroit was very crispy, bordering on dry, with sauce bordering on too salty... the grandma was the best of the 3 in all aspects... ratios and bake were right on...THEN we ordered a full detroit pie and a full grandma to go, and wouldn’t you know they were much different than the slices!? The grandma was thicker, a bit over-baked and did not live up to the slice... the detroit pie was cooked very well and had a better flavor than the slice... the place is very nice and has a great atmosphere... i would definitely recommend checking this place out... but i urge them to focus a bit more on consistency... score is combined between slices and full pies
giveital6812/11/19, 2:08 a.m.
Nice thin pizza no flop taste like it was made in the city and Bronx Brooklyn Queens really really good pizza little greasy but I like a little grease
larry.h9/3/19, 7:07 p.m.
Plain and sicilian slice both pretty bad. Both taste reheated. Good sauce on sicilian slice but not much saucey flavor on plain slice. 5.3 all around BONUS REVIEW: Dr. Pepper available 20 oz bottles and the fountain. I did not try the fountain soda.
zachary.worthington4/28/19, 12:47 a.m.
I was super excited to try this place. The rating is for the plain slice. This is the place to go if you want variety! They have 4 different styles of crust that i seen, a thin crust, a thicker crust, a detroit style crust, and a wood fired pizza. I’d rate the wood-fired the same as the plain slice. The detroit style was pretty unique. It was a lot crunchier and lighter than the detroit style pizzas i have had in the Buffalo, Ny area. Super buttery crunchy crust though, sauce was a little spicy on the detroit style, not just “white people spicy” it actually had a considerable amount of red pepper flake in it or something, but i found it kind of acidic. All around it was very tasty and I’d rate the detroit style a 7.6.
daniel.dorazio4/27/19, 11:31 p.m.
This place has a viriaty of styles of pizza. The straight NY style is good to go at a 7.5 The wood fired pizza was a 7.2 but the thicker crust pizza was where its at. It was very different, super crispy crunch, my favorite of the 3 at a 8.1