D'Onofrio's Pizza

Considering areas choices not too bad so 7.1. Compared to NY or New Haven 4.8.

Great looking pizza. Just in looks this pizza is in the 8s. Unfortunately it doesn’t score high in taste. If you like a crispy crust with no flop, this pizza delivers it. That’s the good part. The cheese is just okay. It needed more of a kick. The sauce was not my style. Too sweet. The pizza was edible but the sauce was a buzzkill for me. I can’t see myself coming back here.

I was finished shopping at the Oldsmar flea market and I found this place on this one bite app, just 3 miles away. 1. They sell by the slice and offer very friendly service. 2. The undercarriage was top notch, no room for improvement. 3. Both the cheese and the sauce were good. I do think it could have use a bit more kick to the sauce though. Cheese was run of the mill, rather decent tasting, but I could name a couple other places nearby that are slightly higher up their brand of cheese.

New York-style pizza - I ordered the large 18” cheese. Good undercarriage with minimal flop. The pizza was foldable yet crispy. Tomato sauce to cheese ratio was good with very little grease and no sogginess. Overall, good “football” pizza as Dave would say. It wasn’t special but I’d be happy to eat it every weekend.

Nice and crunchy but sauces needs more tang. Pleasantly surprised!

This was by my camera man Joshy he gave it a 7.9 he said best pizza in Tampa also very great customer service they deserve more business

First off the girl behind the counter was cute as hell, gray yoga pants, pretty face nice personality. I was trying to flirt with her about how people don’t know how to tip but I don’t know if it worked, she’s an 8.4 for sure. The pizza was ok, pretty standard football pizza, nice crust very light and flakey, no flop, cheese was good sauce was pretty standard and could use a little more herbs and a kick.

Decent pizza, dripping grease, crust is average