Eagles Pizza

Overall forgettable. Lot of nostalgia for folks that live here but would rather stick to places I know then come back. Crust is the best part of the pizza, sauce is bland, cheese is decent.

Classic tavern style Cbus cut on this pie. Dough and crust was pretty unique. Almost like pastry dough. Flaky but still held it’s structural integrity.

Consistently good. Been around for years. One of the best in New Albany!

Good stuff

Not as good as it once was. Not cooked to crispy and toppings were a bit thrown unevenly. But still a decent pie.

These scores are crazy, have y’all had any other pizza?!?! The crust is crisp, no flavor. The sauce is average and the cheese is normal. At least the pepperoni curled. Very over priced

Loaded up on toppings. But the overall crust, cheese and quality of the pie was outstanding.

Pizza and subs are yummy. Me an my friend’s like to eat them. The cinamin pizza is very good to. So I think it is a good food.

Sauce is great and has a nice crisp

Sauce and crust were tasteless. Too many better pizza places around to order again

Thin, crispy crunch, great pizza.

Good quality and great service A lot of flop could have use another minute or two in the oven for me but definitely a great value and homie atmosphere .

Crispy, crackery crust. Good amount of cheese, but lacking enough sauce and what sauce is on there isn’t too flavorful.

Crust needs more snap. Good sauce and fresh toppings

It’s a good pizza, but I love meatball pizza. When’s. Resturant makes spaghetti and meatballs and meatball subs and refuses to put the meatballs on the pizza I usually knock it down over a point.

My favorite pizza in Central Ohio!!