Top Restaurants

Earl's

64-974 Mamalahoa Hwy, Waimea, HI

Pizza Review

1 like

forrest.wolfe on One Bite Pizza App

forrest.wolfe

12/30/22 11:17 PM

Definitely one of the if not the best pizza on the island. Definitely the most NYC style you will find and the closest to what Portnoy likes. Significant flop is the only reason the score isn’t higher. Pay no attention to the 1.7 review below, this pizza is very good and its a shame one review from one person solely because that person felt slighted by whomever was working that day brings the score down so much.

Pizza Review

peterslusinski3/13/25, 10:20 p.m.

7.5

Dave feature in this pic. Good sauce

Pizza Review

peter.conkey12/28/23, 6:01 a.m.

6.1

Good undercarriage and flop. If you’re judging a book by it’s cover it looks absolutely stunning to the eye. But when you get into it the sauce it sweet and kinda takes over the pizza. Good price tho.

Pizza Review

phil.mcgarr4/29/23, 6:47 a.m.

7.9

Fantastic upcountry thin crust pizza. BYOB on alcohol. Best pizza on Big Island.

Pizza Review

jeff.volk3/10/23, 4:16 p.m.

7.5

Very solid NY-style pizza anywhere, but especially on the island. Crust was done well underneath. Sauce does have a little different tasting tang to it. Quality ingredients. The 1.7 score below is absurd.

Pizza Review

robbie.evans18/1/21, 4:31 a.m.

7.6

I enjoyed this pizza. After a long day of hiking I swung by the best pizza in Hawaii on a lark and grabbed a slice. It was tasty! Thinnish crust with a nice sweetness and a real crunch. Pepperoni was solid but I also got the spinach garlic just to try it and it was good. I’m guessing a balance of multiple cheeses. Real good pizza and an island surprise to be honest.

prettywoman8/1/19, 12:45 a.m.

1.7

Yeah taste like Costco ... place was dirty. Customer service lacks tact !

53 views•2 likes

Pizza Review

kel.baby5/25/19, 11:01 p.m.

7.3

Solid all around slice. Tomato sauce has a Campbell’s tomato soup taste. Not bad but ...... Asked for well done crust and it has some nice crunch. Left satisfied.