East Village Pizza

Although I didn't jog down the street like Dave did when he reviewed this spot many years ago, I walked here from Grand Central. I'm glad I did, and I'm walking back. The Margherita slice is amongst the best I ever had. The sauce was amazing, the basil leaves looked pretty and the parm on top was a nice touch. The pepperoni and jalapeños slice was full of flavor and was spicy but nowhere near spicy enough to burn my mouth! 8.3 to both slices Must stop here, worth the money!

Great crust, nice under carriage, worth trying for sure.

Perfect crust. Perfect sauce. Perfect cheese ..

Crispy, hot, and overall great slice of pizza on a cold NYC day. If you like cheesy pizza, this place is for you. Would’ve given an even higher score if it had more sauce, but such is life.

great drunk pie

The plain slices is pretty solid..

Definitely 8. Probably the best margherita pizza slice..

Delicious Margherita Pizza..

I’ve been wanting to try this place for so long, and it didn’t disappoint! Great if you like a NY slice/football pizza. It was cooked well with good crunch/crisp but not burnt.

hearty oily

Pepperoni was fresh and solid and deserved the 7.8. Margherita left a little to be desired and would be a 6.2

Place definitely gets more hype than I think deserved. It’s an above average slice with bland taste. Dough is a bit thicker and crunchier than a traditional NY slice which I thought hurt the pizza a bit. The Grandma I’d rank a 6.8. I felt the dough really didn’t stand out and was similar to the plain slice which was odd for a grandma. Overall it’s a cool vibe in the place but the pizza is not something I’d go out of my way for.

Taste was decent, too greasy to enjoy and not enough sauce

solid nyc slice. crispy but lack of flavor in the sauce.

honestly better than a few places i’ve tried here so far! it actually has flavor. good pie

solid pizza. crispy undercarriage. little greasy though and I would’ve liked more sauce