Eataly NYC Downtown

Great tasting crust. Pretty generous with the toppings too. Def can go back to try some of the other pies.

Presentation is great a crust has just the right crunch

All around incredible

2nd time eating here and confused why such bad reviews. This pizza is literally one of my all time favorites while visiting the city. The crust is the best of any pizza joint I've ever ate at. The flavor is excellent. Super thin. Fresh buffalo mozzarella and basil. The only negative would be the watery wet center of the pie but the all around review still pushes this pie up the ranks of the highest reviews ever.

Crispy good focaccia style crust. Could use more basil. Cheese was the highlight.

No crisp, cheese completely fell off, very doughy

Good not great. I had higher expectations. Service is wonderful. If your downtown it’s worth a trip.

You need to ask if you want tomato sauce on the pizza, otherwise just bread and cheese. People who work here are great. Pizza just ok.

Solid pizza. Tried a few different pizzas in Eataly and they were all delicious.