Perfect thin crust pizza. The best 270 calories ever.
shanna.sobel1/7/21, 2:40 a.m.
Paper Thin! Was the thinnest of the thin for what concerns bar pie. I liked it, but thought it was missing something. Was a bit bland in flavor. Overall, decent bar pie!!
goblue_84512/19/20, 5:14 p.m.
For the last fifteen years, Eddie’s has been my personal favorite, hands down; paper thin, crispy crust with fresh mozzarella and authentic homemade sauce. Whether you’re dining in or taking a pie to an Islanders tailgate, Eddie’s unquestionably lands in the upper echelon of pizzerias in the northeast.
neil.tortorelli9/24/20, 9:12 p.m.
Pres must've gotten a much better pie than me. Maybe its because of covid?
mickeyhits8/3/20, 11:10 p.m.
Pizza on a tortilla...I get it is supposed to be bar pizza but this pizza was lacking a lot. We also got the Eddy Special which was much better but the review is strictly on the original cheese bar pie.
evanrhodes37/17/20, 12:31 a.m.
Shit. Cash only, had never heard of a transfusion, and the pizza took a while. If you’re in the area, go to Umberto’s of new Hyde and get the Sicilian! Also way overpriced, I don’t care if they’re the home of the bar pie or not, it’s basically on a tortilla. Won’t be coming back even though it’s less than 10 minutes away, hence the bad score
dominic.annese5/30/20, 2:31 a.m.
Nice pie. Lacking the crisp to make it an 8.1. Id imagine if it was well done and you ate it inside it would easily be an 8 or 8.1 Cool vibe in this place definitely worth stopping in for a drink at least
amordepizza5/12/20, 4:12 p.m.
This review is about the “bar pie” thin pie as it is supposed to be. Little salty for my taste. The sauce a little bland. Good crisp on the crust but overall I really excepted more from this place. No flop on the slice as well which is always a positive.
charles.tetro3/20/20, 11:35 p.m.
Pretty good bar pie with a crispy thin crust, but too much cheese & not enough sauce. The Eddie’s Special is better though the heavy toppings are not well supported by the Matzo crust.
yarms2/9/20, 7:34 p.m.
*review based on plain side* good pie but something was missing. Remember it being much better but still decent.
nick.reilly11/26/20, 9:05 p.m.
Have been going here since a kid always have been consistently great. Bar pies all day.
blade.nunley8/18/19, 7:20 p.m.
Great bar pizza, a little short on the crisp factor but all around strong slice